Erica

You are pretty sure that Ashley's dad would have you killed or you would wish you were dead if you tried to raise your child with her. Karen's mom and step-dad hate you. So your best chance is with Erica. You go back to her two weeks after she told you she is pregnant and tell her you want to try a relationship.

After it is announced to her parents (you and Erica make up a story of dark drunken one time conception) they are fairly cool. Erica was going to Woocott mostly to play tennis. Her dad is a beer distributor and she is an only child. She will finish up her education at G.R.V.C.C. after the child is born. Your mom freaks until you and Erica agree to get married before the kid is born. Two months after you fucked her, you hear that Agnes is knocked her up as well and she conceived about that time.