Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 35 by The Smutsketeer The Smutsketeer

What's next?

Discussing your ex

"So who's Alison?" Carmen asked later as you sat on the couch together.

"An ex" you said.

"How come you still talk to her?" she wanted to know.

"Honestly? I forgot I still had her in my phone book. I haven't spoken to her in months" you told her.

"You promise?" Carmen asked.

"I swear" you said with a smile. "I asked you to marry me. If I had gotten bored enough to want to go back to an ex I would not have done that."

"What's she look like?" your fiancé asked. You pulled up Alison's profile on social media and showed it to Carmen. The young woman took your phone and began browsing through your ex's profile. "What happened to break you two up?" she asked next.

"She moved away from here and I stayed" you said. "Is it really necessary for you to know all this? I chose you, not her."

"I'm sorry" Carmen said, "I just want to know the competition."

"Are you feeling threatened?" you asked with a grin.

"Hm..." she said, thinking it over. "Just territorial."

"Oh? You don't want to share me with my ex?" you teased.

"Well, you do have enough cock to go around" Carmen mused. "But I'd rather share you with Luci than some random slut."

"Wow, you are perverted" you said with a laugh.

"I mean, not actually share you that way" Carmen said, smirking. "I didn't mean kneeling next to her in front of you, having the both of us use our tongues to please you."

"Now I want that" you teased.

"Dream on. You're marrying me, not Luci, not this Alison chick, not anybody else. Just me" she said.

"Alright, alright" you said, "nobody else. Just you." It was then that you remembered the auction. "Do you think we would have gotten together if not for the auction?" you asked.

"I don't know" she said, "maybe."

"What if I'd chosen to date Rose or Debbie?" you said.

"Then I would never have known just how wonderful you are" Carmen said, hugging you tight.

"High praise coming from someone as wonderful as you are" you replied as you kissed her forehead.

"You know just how to butter me up" Carmen said with a laugh.

"For what?" you asked. "I'm just giving you a compliment."

"Suuuure" Carmen replied, grinning. "Are you sure you aren't trying to make that threesome a reality?"

"Which one? You and my ex or you and your sister?" you asked.

"You, sir, are a disgusting pervert and I love it, but there's no way I'm ever going to share you with my sister unless I get brain damage or something" Carmen said.

"Duly noted. On a completely unrelated note, have you ever done any erotic asphyxiation?" you asked with a straight face. Carmen laughed and pushed you on your back.

"You are the worst" she said as she climbed on top of you. Laughing you put your arms around her and held her close.

"You still love me in spite of it" you said.

"Hey, I can still break off the engagement" Carmen replied.

"If you do that" you said, teasing right back, "I'm plowing Luci."

"You hussy!" Carmen said with a giggle. "On second thought, I might as well try marriage with you."

"Damn" you said, making her laugh some more.

"You're such a goofball. I love you, John" she said.

"I love you too, Carmen. Soon to be Carmen Doe" you replied.

"I like that name" she said, repeating it for good measure. "Carmen Doe. Yeah, that sounds good."

"What about Luciana Doe?" you ventured.

"Ass" Carmen said, laughing. "I love you so much but dammit if I'm not going to start punching you if you keep teasing me like that."

"Alright, alright. No more talk about Luci" you said, pausing for effect. "Then what about your mom?"

Carmen laughed even louder and playfully punched your chest. "Take that, you horrible monster" she said. Laughing too, you grabbed her wrists to stop her from doing it again and sat up.

"Oh yeah?" you asked, "so what are you going to do now that this monster has you where he wants you to be?"

"Probably get bent over and have my ass eaten yet again" Carmen said.

"Is that what you fear or what you hope for?" you replied.

"Either or" Carmen said, grinning.

"Well, you'd be wrong. I need some more practice finding your pussy" you told her.

"We have over a year left before I graduate. I intend to get you there in due time" Carmen replied as her hand found its way to your crotch. "God, we do a lot of fucking, don't we?" she said.

"Do you mind?" you asked.

"Fuck no!" Carmen exclaimed with a loud laugh. "Just an observation."

What's next?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)