Caught By Faranne

As soon as she opened the door, she was shocked, when she saw Finn having sex with Lilith, and sharing a passionate kiss, that would have made an otherwise delightful sight, if not for the fact that Finn was fucking her sister. Faranne was stunned, and in denial, from seeing them two lying on the bed, and making out, something she hoped would never happen. But now, that it was occuring right in front of her eyes, she couldn't be more upset, from the fact that everything she didn't wish for, had actually happened, and she believed it was all Finn's fault.

"Oh my... what are you two doing??..." - Faranne exclaimed, just to get Finn's and Lilith's attention, and confirm that they were indeed having sex, and not just intimately hugging. But as the two of them heard Faranne's voice, they instantly froze with fear, and very slowly, turned their attention to her, to find her more annoyed than ever. Lilith was just extremely embarrassed, and couldn't do anything, except hide her blushin face, and try to cover her naked body, while Finn felt his heart stop, as he realized he had made a huge mistake. But since he couldn't say anything, and Faranne saw that they were indeed having sex, she couldn't be more mad about it.

"I knew it... I fucking knew it... Finn, how could you?? Why did yo-..." - Faranne asked to herself, and Finn, as she wasn't able to control her intense frustration, and even hate, from seeing him having sex with her sister. What bothered her the most, was the fact that she warned him a couple times before, and she believed he would have understood, but now, that it was clear he didn't, Faranne felt like Finn betrayed him, by breaking his word, and losing her trust. And after he saw Faranne's reaction, he immediately knew he had to do something to solve, or get out of this situation, even though he felt like there was no point in arguing with her, since he was already caught.

"Wait, I can explain!... I wasn't doing what you think... w-we were just-..." - Finn quickly tried to justify himself, as he, and Lilith, were in a state of panic, that was amplified by Faranne's intense, and judgmental staring. They both knew they were doing something wrong, and that's why they were so embarassed, and ashamed, when Faranne caught them having sex. But while Lilith just felt bad, from knowing her sister wasn't going to see her in the same way anymore, she felt worse for Finn, since she knew she got them both in trouble. And because he felt like it was all his fault, Finn felt so terrible, he immediately tried to apologize, or come up with an argument, but he wasn't able to, since Faranne interrupted him.

"No, I don't want to hear it... Put your clothes on and come with me right now, young man... And for you Lilith... stay here, I will have a talk with you later..." - Faranne commanded, with a menacing tone, that gave both Finn, and Lilith shivers, that made them follow her order immediately. Faranne wasn't here to hear any of Finn's excuses, and he knew that, so that's why he quickly got up from bed, put on his clothes, and as scary as it was, had to walk with her out the door. And even though Lilith wasn't going to see what her sister had to say to her, or not until much later, she could only watch in fear, as Finn was going to get a hard scolding, and feeling powerless, she also feared for him, and herself, since Lilith knew she wasn't going to get away with this so easily.

But after putting on his clothes, and leaving the catgirl's bed, Finn couldn't bring himself to look at Lilith, from the shame he felt, or even Faranne, from the threatening she looked. But since he didn't have any choice at the moment, he only followed the angry Faranne out of her sister's house, and leaving the catgirl behind, he started shaking, from fearing what Faranne was going to do with him. She didn't say anything for a while, as they walked near to her house, which only made things more tense for him, and while he knew he was in trouble, Finn hoped Faranne wouldn't take it too seriously, and he could somehow be forgiven. But after they walked for a while, Faranne stopped, turned around, and she was about to show him how he was wrong, and that he was in serious trouble, because she was more irritated than ever.

"Why Finn?? WHY??... What is your problem??... I told you... I told you many times... Don't have sex with Lilith!... I made it pretty clear that I don't want her messing around with you... So fully knowing that... WHY DID YOU STILL HAVE SEX WITH MY SISTER??" - Faranne asked, enraged, and utterly in disbelief, from seeing how Finn disobeyed her, and messed with her sister, even when she warned him multiple times. And as Finn was able to see the rage in her eyes, he immediately knew there was no getting away from this, and already regretting his decision, he decided to try apologize, just to see if he could get some pity out of Faranne, and if he was lucky enough, get her to understand him.

"I'm so sorry... I knew it was wrong... I didn't want to do it... but then I thought you were not going to find out an-..." - Finn tried to reply, without actually giving any reason, or argument, to justify what he did with Lilith. He wasn't able to think very well, since his mind was tormented by the strong fear of Faranne hating him, after realizing she was very mad at him, for good reasons. Finn was already imagining all the things that could happen to him, or how Faranne would stop loving him, but he didn't expect his response to get her angrier.

"So you slept with Lilith because you believed you could keep it a secret from me??... I knew you were going to do that... but for how long have you been doing it??" - Faranne asked, with more of an infuriating curiosity, from thinking that Finn was lying to him, and had been having sex with Lilith for a while. And as soon as he saw her reaction, Finn got very nervous, from trying to come up with an answer, as he didn't know what to say, or what he even felt. He couldn't figure out the reason he had messed with the catgirl, but he quickly tried to remember, and in a desperate attempt of saving himself, Finn thought it would be a good idea to shift the blame at Lilith, as she did actually have something to do with this, and was the one that provoked him.

"Uhh... the day when we went to the forest... but that's because Lilith was the one that told me to come visit her... She stole a kiss from me!! She was the one to entice me to do all those naughty things to her!! She isn't as innocent as you think!!" - Finn blurted out in panic, as he tried to explain himself, and justify his actions, by revealing the intentions of the catgirl, that Faranne has as a sister. But even though she was suspicious of Lilith, and could believe how she would do something like that with Finn, Faranne felt like that wasn't a good reason, for him to keep talking with her sister, and ending up having sex with her.

"You couldn't control yourself and now you are blaming my sister for your awful mistakes??... Unbelievable..." - Faranne asked, with an aggressive sarcastic tone, and said under her breath, as she was greatly disappointed of Finn. Not from the pure fact of him having sex with Lilith, but from not being able to control himself, be tempted by his desires, and even lying to her, which was what really hurt her. But as Finn saw Faranne's infuriated face, he knew he couldn't say anything else, and since there was no point in arguing, he thought he just had to keep his mouth shut, and wait for her to say something. And after she saw Finn's distressed frown, Faranne realized how truly sorry he was, and tried to be more flexible, since she genuinely felt bad for him, and wanted to understand his situation, so they could solve this problem together.

"Look... I'm not mad... well, I am a little... but I just want to understand, why did you do this?? Why did you have sex with my sister??" - Faranne asked, with a more calm, but still clearly annoyed voice, that was soft enough, to make Finn a little comfortable. He still knew he was in trouble, and he got her to pretty much hate him, but after seeing how Faranne wasn't that aggressive anymore, Finn tried to think of a response, so he could actually talk to her, and explain what had happened.

"Uhh... I don't know how to respond to that..." - Finn replied, with a soft, nervous voice, since he actually couldn't figure out why he had sex with the catgirl. He tried to search in her dumb, horny mind, to remember what happened that first night with Lilith, where he was tempted by her, and ended up fingering her. And as it was clear he didn't have an answer, Faranne tried to help Finn, so he could remember better, by making her question clearer, and hopefully getting an answer from him.

"You already have Zoey as your girlfriend... you could have all sorts of fun with Katsumi... or even get naughty with Sayuri... You also have me to spoil you and have sex with... So why involve Lilith in all of this??" - Faranne asked, a bit more frustrated, but mainly confused, as she tried getting a clear response from Finn, who had a hard time processing her question. He finally realized how dumb his decision was, since he had many girls in his life to have sex with, and he still found the need to mess with Lilith. But as Finn couldn't figure out why he had sex with the catgirl, he started searching deeper inside him, and found one of his concerns, that he had forgotten earlier, but was now very prominent, for some reason, probably because he was being questioned so much.

"I'm just so worried about some things... I needed to clear my mind with something... a-and I saw everyone was busy... or fighting with each other... Lilith was like the only one that I knew I could relax at that moment... I swear to you I didn't mean any harm to her... I tried being as gentle as possible with her an-... Sorry, I know it was dumb... I should just shut up..." - Finn replied, with an anxious frown, as he couldn't find the reason he had sex with Lilith, and instead, found something else, that was just as, or even more worrying. But as he tried explaining himself, Finn felt like his response didn't make much sense, or it wasn't relevant to the question Faranne made, so he tried to give up on reasoning with himself.

And although Faranne didn't know what he was talking about, she immediately realized what were some of his problems that were affecting him so much recently. She remembered Finn still had a bunch of questions, that he actually asked her yesterday, but they were not able to discuss them, since the whole threesome thing happened. So after all the fun from last night, and getting very angry at him, Faranne tried to calm herself down, and forget a bit about her sister, since was ready to answer most of Finn's doubts. So as Faranne really wanted to talk abou Finn's worries, she quickly tried to make him speak more on the matter, to prioritize his concerns, and discuss his mistake of having sex with Lilith later.

"Wait!... No, it's okay... I understand what you are going through... but please, let me know what your problem is... If you still have any doubts to solve, you should tell them to me... I will try my best to help you..." - Faranne said, with a more reassuring voice, and very comforting smile, as she tried encouraging Finn to speak. And even though Faranne clearly was there to help him, Finn hesitated, as he still felt bad for being caught fucking her catgirl sister. But as he realized Faranne was pushing her angry, and worries about that topic aside, to solely focus on him, Finn felt a bit safer, from seeing Faranne's supporting smile, that told him she changed her mind. So as he got the courage to open up with her, Finn decided to tell Faranne everything he was thinking of, and why he was concerned, hoping to get a good answer, so he could finally solve all of his doubts, that were still bothering him, even after a few days, and countless sex.