Carli came back.

A few days later, the four of you were watching TV. David was on the couch between Jesse and Joan. Each girl had a hand on his thigh. Joan started moving her hand back and forth, getting farther up his thigh and closer to his crotch. Jesse noticed the movement and started nuzzling David's neck.

You were sitting next to the couch, on the floor. You were clothed, but when you saw what the girls were doing, you started taking off your shirt. This type of activity always led to the same place, and the three of them always wanted you to be naked while you jerked off and watched them fuck. Doing what they wanted without being told was the most likely way to get invited to participate in some small, if humiliating way.

However, before you could get your shirt off, the doorbell rang.

"Get the door, John," said David without even looking up from the TV. The girls relaxed and turned back to the TV, but they kept their hands on his thighs.

You got up and let your shirt drop back down. When you opened the door, you were surprised to see Carli.

"Hi John. Can I come in?"

"Um, just a sec, let me check," you answered.

"Who is it?" asked David.

"It's Carli."

"Just her? Not her boyfriend? Well, fuck, my man! Let her in!"

You gestured for Carli to come inside. She walked in front of the couch. David looked up at her like a king on his throne while Jesse and Joan cuddled up against him from both sides.

"Um, I've been doing a lot of thinking since we left," said Carli, glancing quickly at David's crotch before looking away.

"I bet you have."

"I... I just don't think what you did was right. You and Jesse." She involuntarily glanced down at his crotch again. It wasn't clear if she'd even registered that Jesse and Joan were in the room. "I mean, it wasn't fair. To John."

"Bullshit!"

"Um, excuse me?"

"You're not here about that piece of shit. You saw the big meat last time, and you want to see it again. Well, I can take care of that."

"No, I... I... oh my god." Carli's weak protests stopped as David pulled out his huge cock. She stared at it while he and the two other girls smiled knowingly. Finally she said, "Please."

David laughed. "Please what?"

"Please... fuck me. I've never, um..."

"You've never had a cock this big before, have you."

She swallowed. "No."

Jesse yelled, "No, SIR!"

She took a step back, but her eyes went right back to his incredible cock. "No, sir."

Jesse stood up and walked up close to Carli. Her voice was still soft, but it had an edge to it you'd never heard before. "You said a lot of mean things about me before you left, Carli. A lot of judgmental things that hurt me. We knew you'd come back, any girl would come back after seeing that cock. But we have some conditions."

Carli gulped hard. She looked at Joan, who had a classic super-villain smile. Then she looked at David's cock again for a long time before turning back to Jesse and saying, "Anything."