Caitlyn

Josh had moved himself and Tiana to face the entrance to her room. At the other side of it stood Caitlyn, Tiana’s roommate and behind her stood someone else, a man similar in size to Josh. Josh didn’t pay as much or almost any attention to him, seeing as it was hard for him to take his eyes off of Caitlyn.

Caitlyn had the same perfect chocolate skin as Tiana. She had nice long black hair that wasn’t frizzy like Tiana’s but smooth and glanced in the light, brown eyes and beautiful lips Josh wouldn’t mind spreading apart with his cock when he was done with Tiana. Her tits were at least double Ds but still looked as firm as Tiana’s Cs. At least one thing Tiana and Caitlyn had in common was their magnificent asses and accompanying thighs. Despite Josh not being able to see Caitlyn’s ass, due to her facing Josh, he could tell he just had to have a piece of it when he was done with Tiana.

Caitlyn eyed Tiana up and down quickly, paying extra attention to the streaks of cum on Tiana’s naked body and the steady stream of cum coming out of her cunt and ass.

“I fucking knew it! All high and mighty Tiana taking it up every hole she has just like everybody else!” Caitlyn said with a smug face.

“Hi Caitlyn, this is… Jooosh, I met... hiiim earlier today, he really iiiss… something else, I tell you!” Tiana said while trying to have her body match the rhythm that Josh was going at.

“Sure Tiana, that’s what they all say... Hey Josh maybe you’d like to join me and my friend Mike here in a moment? I’m sure you’re gonna get tired of fucking a virgin, ain’t you? You need someone with REAL skill.” Said Caitlyn while looking at Josh, making an inviting face.

“Hey! I’m just as good at fucking as you are! I’ve made Josh cum several times already!” Tiana protested. In her outburst she broke the rhythm she was keeping with Josh, almost making Josh lose his grip on her.

“Sweetie, you can’t even keep his dick in your ass.” Caitlyn said with a grin and then continued, “But I have an idea. If you’re so good at sex let’s take turns at fucking Mike and Josh? Let them decide who they prefer of the two of us.”

“I’m in. I’m not gonna pass up the opportunity to fuck two the hottest black girls in college” Mike said.

“I know you are honey.” Caitlyn said and she turned to face Mike, put her hand on his crotch and started to rub it up and down. If his dick wasn’t hard before from watching Tiana getting ass fucked in her room it was now.

“What do you think Josh?” Tiana said.

“Yeah Josh? You ready to fuck a REAL woman?” Caitlyn said. Clearly the question was formally directed towards Josh, but Caitlyn had only made it to taunt Tiana into accepting the bet.

Josh was thinking deeply about it. He could just settle and continue to fuck Tiana. She might not be able to take his dick in her cunt and not pass out but her ass more than made up for that. He could accept her as his third girlfriend and have his libido continuously gratified by her ass if he wanted to. On the other hand, her friend Caitlyn did look pretty hot and why should he turn an opportunity for more sex down? Sure, he had to share her with this Mike fellow, but her rack and ass looked pretty inviting and he was getting tired of just fucking Tiana’s ass despite of how amazing it was. Variety is the spice of life after all.