Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 8 by Fitfully_Yours Fitfully_Yours

Phil's choice

Ass

Phil licked his lips, knowing he had always wanted to fuck Gloria's pussy, but her ass had been a subject of wonder since before they had been introduced. Phil and Claire had been invited to the party, and Jay had pointed out the woman who would become his wife, wearing a slinky dress that accentuated her ass.

Looking back on it now, he realized that with the possibility that this would never happen again, he just couldn't pass up the opportunity to take what he had lusted over for so long. Phil bent his knees, lining his cock up with her puckered sphincter, smearing precum against her flesh. Her ass pulled away as she clenched her muscles at the first touch of his cock. "No, not even Chay would do that!"

"You've never been fucked in the ass?" Phil asked.

"No, eets so dirty," Gloria moaned, hoping Phil was seeing the futility and evil that he had momentarily occupied his mind.

"It is dirty, isn't it?" Phil agreed, pushing the tip against her sphincter until it popped inside.

Gloria screamed in embarrassment and pain as Phil **** more of his cock into her bowels, deeper and deeper until his hips rested against her upper thighs and ass cheeks. "You know," Phil gloated, leaning over her back, "when I first saw your ass, I'd have never guessed it to be virgin."

"Please take eet out, eet hurts so bad!" she pleaded, her fingers curling into the sheets.

"Fine, I'll take it out," he said, pulling his cock half way out of Gloria's ass before slamming his way back in, rocking her body forward on the bed. "Oh, sorry, did I not take it out?" he mocked her, thrusting again and again, making her gasp in pain with each thrust.

As horny as Phil had been the entire day, he didn't last long in Gloria's formerly virgin ass, and he cried out as he sunk as deep as he could inside her ass, his cock throbbing as he filled her colon with sperm.

"Damn, that was fun," Phil husked, sliding a hand from her ankle, letting it fall as he grabbed her breast. "We're going to have to do this again."

"Never!" she spit at him, trying to push Phil away.

"Oh, never say never," Phil said, swatting her hand away only to go back to caress her breast. "After all, I know where you live, and I know where your children live, don't I?"

Gloria's mouth dropped in shock at the mere suggestion of harm to her kids. "You wouldn't!"

"That depends on how you react next time I tell you I want to fuck, doesn't it?"

What's next?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)