Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 6 by MetaWithAMouth MetaWithAMouth

What Happens When They Get Home?

A Playful Push

Inside, the house was a cool sanctuary, scented with Elena's lavender candles—living room cluttered with the remaining moving boxes, a reminder of their recent move. Jordan kicked off the pink ballet flats, the relief immediate, but the thigh-high stockings and the sundress clung to him, amplifying his vulnerability. He headed for the stairs, **** to change, but Elena caught his arm gently.

"Wait," she said, her voice softening as she led him to the couch. "Let's talk first. Come on." They sat, the sundress pooling around Jordan's thighs, the stockings whispering against the couch. Elena knelt in front of him, her hands on his knees, her touch electric through the nylon.

"Jordan, what happened… it was a mistake, sure. But it was also… revealing." Her fingers traced the dress's hem, slow and deliberate, sending a shiver up his spine. "I saw how you reacted when they dressed you up. There was something there, wasn't there? A spark?"

Jordan's face burned, his cheeks crimson. He wanted to deny it—the softness of the stockings, the way the dress hugged his slight frame, had stirred something unsettling, a warmth that mingled shame with an unwelcome thrill.

"It was humiliating," he whispered, but his body betrayed him, a tremor in his legs as her hand lingered. "Everyone was staring. I just wanted to disappear."

Elena's smile was gentle but knowing.

"Maybe. But you didn't disappear. You played along, and it worked. They all thought you were Joanne—my friend." She paused, her eyes searching his. "And I have to admit… seeing you like that, so ****, so… different… it did something to me." Her voice was low, confessional, her fingers squeezing his knee. "I liked it, Jordan. A lot."

He swallowed hard, torn between embarrassment and the pull of her words. "You're serious?" he asked, his voice trembling. "You liked seeing me like that?"

She nodded, standing and walking up the stairs toward the master bathroom.

"Dead serious. Hold on—let me grab a few things. maybe we could try something. Just for us."" She disappeared briefly, returning with mascara, blush, pink lip gloss, a bottle of soft rose nail polish, and A BRA!!

"Thought… maybe we could try something. Just for us."

Jordan's eyes widened, his heart pounding. "Elena, no. I'm not putting on makeup...and a bra...no way. The festival was bad enough."

She sat beside him, the items between them, her hand resting on his thigh, her touch warm through the nylon.

"Hear me out. It's just a game, Jordan. A way to take back what happened, make it ours. No one else will know—just us." Her voice was coaxing, her eyes bright with excitement. "Let me do your makeup and nails. If you hate it, we stop. But… I think you might like it more than you're letting on." Her fingers squeezed gently, a silent plea, and he felt that flutter again—stronger now, undeniable.

He hesitated, his mind a whirlwind. Part of him wanted to bolt, to strip off the outfit and erase the night. But Elena's gaze—so full of affection and curiosity—held him. Their marriage thrived on her nudging him into new experiences, and deep down, the memory of the tent—the softness of the fabric, the way it made him feel seen in a strange new way—whispered to him.

"Fine," he sighed, his cheeks burning. "But only because you asked. And we're never telling anyone."

Elena's face lit up, a grin spreading as she opened the lip gloss. "Stay right here—let me work my magic."

She started with the nail polish, unscrewing the rose bottle and taking his hand. The brush glided cool over his nails, the scent sweet and chemical, each stroke deliberate. Jordan watched, mesmerized and mortified, as his fingertips turned glossy pink. She blew gently to dry them, her breath warm on his skin. Next, the blush—a soft puff on his cheeks, turning his flush into something intentional. Mascara followed, her steady hand lengthening his lashes, making his eyes look wider, more ****. Finally, the pink lip gloss, slick and sticky, tasting faintly of cherry as she smoothed it with her thumb.

After the nail polish had dried, Elena picked the soft pink bra she had brought from the vanity—light padding tucked inside to give a subtle, natural curve.

“Arms up, Joanne,” she murmured, slipping the straps over his shoulders and fastening it at the back with a practiced snap. The fabric hugged his chest, the padding settling into a gentle swell that pressed softly against the sundress bodice. She adjusted the cups with teasing fingers, pulling in the little fat he had on his chest, her thumbs brushing his nipples through the lace trim until they peaked, sending a fresh shiver down his spine. “There—now nothing’s amiss.”

Elena stepped back, then led him to the full-length mirror. She brushed his shoulder-length hair into loose waves, tying a simple white ribbon.

"There. Look at yourself, Joanne. It suits you."

Jordan stared at his reflection, his heart racing. The man he knew was gone, replaced by a young woman—the pink sundress accentuating his delicate features, subtle curves swelling softly beneath the bodice, waves bouncing slightly as he moved, rose nails gleaming, glossy lips parted in shock. The stockings hugged his legs, their softness a constant sensation, and the dress moved with him, light and unfamiliar. Humiliation flooded him, hot and unrelenting, but beneath it was that thrill—the makeup's weight, the way Elena's eyes devoured him.

"I look ridiculous," he whispered, but his voice lacked conviction, trembling with a mix of shame and arousal.

Elena stepped behind him, her arms wrapping around his waist, her chin resting on his shoulder as they faced the mirror.

"You look like my little secret," she whispered, her breath warm against his ear. Her hands traced the dress's seams, fingers dipping under the hem, grazing the stockings. "See? It's not so bad. It's… exciting." Her body pressed against his, her arousal palpable, and Jordan felt a surge of heat, his own body responding despite his protests.

"Elena…" he started, but she silenced him with a kiss on his neck, her lips soft and insistent, trailing to his jaw. Her hands roamed—one sliding up his thigh, the other tugging at the dress's buttons, the fabric shifting to expose more of the stockings. The sensation was overwhelming—the nylon's softness, the dress's gentle weight, her touch igniting his skin.

"This is crazy," he gasped, but he leaned into her, the forbidden intimacy pulling him under.

Her lips found his, the kiss deep and possessive—gloss smearing, her hands exploring the sundress's contours, fingers slipping under to caress his stocking-clad thighs.

"You're my Joanne tonight," she murmured, her voice commanding yet tender, guiding him to the couch. The dress rode up as he sat, the stockings sliding against the cushions, amplifying every sensation. Elena straddled him, her weight grounding him, her hands roaming freely now—unbuttoning the sundress to expose his chest, her fingers teasing through the fabric.

"Admit it," she whispered, her lips brushing his ear. "You like this, don't you?"

Jordan's breath hitched, his body trembling with a mix of shame and desire.

"It's… strange," he admitted, his voice barely audible. "But… yeah." The confession felt raw, ****, and Elena's eyes lit up, her arousal fueling their intensity. Her hands moved with purpose—one sliding under the dress to stroke his inner thigh, the other tugging at his hair waves, the ribbon tickling his neck. The stockings, so soft against her touch, sent waves of sensation through him, his arousal building to a fever pitch.

A sharp knock at the door shattered the moment.

Jordan froze, his body still humming from Elena's touch, panic surging through him like ice water. The sundress was half-unbuttoned, the thigh-high stockings rumpled around his thighs, rose nails catching the light, and the ribbon in his waves dangled loosely from her earlier tugs.

"Who the hell is that?"

Elena muttered, glancing at the clock—8:15 PM, the summer sky still twilight-blue outside. She pulled back, straightening her blouse with a frustrated sigh, her cheeks flushed.

Who is at the door?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)