18 years ago...

Nila carried Daniel inside from the rain, stopping only to let him vomit in the bushes. Once they got inside, Daniel soon collapsed on the couch and fell asleep, much to Nila's disappointment. That night was supposed to be the night they both lost their virginity. She felt a tad bit horny, but not for Daniel. Especially with how wasted he'd gotten with the flask he'd smuggled in.

She'd told her parents she was staying at a friend's house that night, but the plan was to stay at Daniel's parent's place. To her knowledge, they'd be the only ones there, as his parents were on holiday, and Kyall was still in college. With that in mind, she went looking for Daniel's room. The first bedroom she found was covered in posters for bands and movies.

After removing her dress, Nila went over to one of the pillows. She'd spent many a night pillow humping with her eyes closed, imaging what the real thing would be like with a real cock. Plus, she imagined she'd leave a scent behind for Daniel to smell when he finally woke up. It'd be the perfect punishment for his little mistake, especially as she had shaven her bush off and gone on the pill just for this night.

As she bucked her hips, she began to moan with pleasure. That's when the door was flung open. In came Kyall, who was wearing a towel around his waist until it got clipped by the doorway. It suddenly came off, revealing his throbbing erection. Nila looked over her shoulder, seeing Kyall and his gym-toned body.

"W-who are you?" Nila crossed her arms over her sizable breasts, even though her back was turned to Kyall.

"I'm Kyall. Daniel's brother."

"I thought you weren't home?"

Kyall shrugged. "Some friends wanted to catch up earlier today."

"Is this your room?"

Kyall nodded.

"Oh my God. I'm so sorry."

"There's no need to be sorry. Is Danny asleep?"

"Yeah."

"Seems like it'd be a real shame to leave you hanging then."

Kyall got onto the bed as Nila froze. Admittedly, Daniel was far from her dream man, being a scrawny little nerd, but he was kind of adorable. But then again, adorable wasn't what she saw when she closed her eyes. No, she saw someone strong and confident, like Brad Pitt or David Beckham, or Kyall. Kyall was the opposite of the boy she pretended to love, and that's why she didn't leave. That's why she turned to face him. That's why let him pull her in for a kiss, and when he drove his tongue down her throat, she returned the favor.

It was a deep, passionate kiss. One that shook her to the core. It was a sin, but it felt like heaven. She let Kyall lay her down on her back, allowing him to put a hand on her slick slit. Two of his fingers slid right inside of her, and reached for her spot with practiced precision, making her gasp in amazement. Next, he put a thumb on her clit and began rubbing. It was like he knew her body better than she did.

"Ohh fuck..." Nila moaned.

"That good babe?"

"Y-yeah..."

"Ever done this before?"

"No."

"You on the pill?"

"Yeah I'm on it."

"Perfect."

Despite how good it felt, Nila couldn't help but feel a pang of guilt for Daniel. He should've been the one experiencing this, but at the same time, he'd blown it by getting wasted. She also knew that he'd be nowhere as good as Kyall was.

"Ohh... Kyall..."

"You getting close?"

Nila nodded, knowing her shivering body betrayed her anyway. Shivering that made Kyall's cock throb. She'd felt Daniel's shaft a few times and even given him a blowjob once before, but his average penis was dwarfed by his brother's larger member. She'd always heard bigger was better from her girlfriends, but part of her wondered if it was true. Then again, if he was half as good with his cock as he was with his fingers, she knew that she was in for an unforgettable experience.

Her body suddenly exploded, quaking with the bliss that took cover. She made no attempt to stifle her cries, which only made her that much more excited. As she continued to convulse, Kyall pried her legs apart, giving him easy access to her pussy. She gave him a meek nod of approval as he pressed inside of her. Despite how bold he'd been, Kyall eased his length inside of her, making sure to be gentle.

"How's that feel?" Kyall asked.

"Ahh... Not bad."

"I'll go easy. Don't worry."

Nila looked to Kyall, who was smiling as he slowly thrusted. Then he leaned down to kiss her lips, and Nila accepted. She knew she was far past the point of no return, but that didn't matter. What did was how good Kyall felt inside of her. She could tell not all of him was inside of her, but she didn't mind. In fact, she appreciated just how gentle he was.

Tenderly, Kyall leaned down and whispered "How does that feel?"

"Ahh... It feels good Kyall."

"Reach down and touch your clit for me."

Nila did just that as Kyall looked into her eyes. She smiled back at the gentle giant on top of her as pleasure began to build once more. Somehow, his cock was right on her spot, again, as if he knew her body better than herself. Some of her friends had said how much their first time had hurt, but any pain had swiftly subsided to pleasure.

"Ahh... Can you go faster?" She cooed.

"Absolutely Nila."

Kyall began pistoning at an increased pace, although he was still holding back. Nila's response was immediate, with her free hand slapping the bedsheets before gripping them, her knuckles turning white as Kyall continued to plow her.

"Ohh fuck yes..."

"That what you want baby?"

"Yes."

"Are you gonna cum for me again?"

"Yes."

"Cum with me babe. Cum with me."

Pistoning faster and faster, Kyall soon pushed himself and Nila over the edge and into a blissful climax, with Nila shuddering underneath him as he unloaded inside of her. Only once her pleasure faded did Nila start to feel a hint of guilt. She did her best to justify why she was still kissing her boyfriend's brother, but deep down she knew it was wrong, even if it had felt so right.