You

“I pick David,” she announced decisively looking straight at me. I looked right back at her enjoying the sight of her panties and bare legs and unconsciously touched the growing bulge in my jeans. “Truth or dare?”

“Dare,” I replied without hesitation. That seemed to make the game more interesting, although Beth refusing a truth had turned out pretty interesting too.

“I think David’s starting to get a little excited playing our little game,” she smiled maliciously. “I think maybe I can help him with that. I dare you to make out with your sister for two minutes,” she grinned.

“Sure,” I smiled. I got up and headed toward where Susie was sitting on the sofa.

“Whoa, just a minute here,” Susie piped up. "Don’t I get a say in this?”

“I don’t think so,” Beth replied. “Unless you want David to lose his dare. Besides you two have already admitted to having the hots for each other.”

I sat down on the sofa next to Susie and looked into her eyes. I could see that she really wanted to do this too, she just didn’t want to admit it. “C’mon, sis, how bad could it be?” I laughed. “I’m really a pretty good kisser, just ask Carly.”

“Yeah, if you don’t want to do it, I’d be glad to take your place,” Carly grinned.

Susie shot darts at her. “Not on your life.” She pulled me toward her and placed her lips firmly against mine. I responded immediately, putting my arms around her slim waist and mushing my lips back against hers with enthusiasm. We started playing with our tongues and biting and pulling each other's lips. Then our lips opened again and we tried to push our tongues as deep into the others' mouth as we could. At the same time, Susie had started stroking my legs working her way closer and closer to my crotch. For my part I let my hands roam freely over her body, feeling her ass inside her tight shorts and actually sliding my hand under her crop top to find she was not wearing a bra. She moaned into my mouth as I cupped the soft flesh of her tit and tweaked her hard nipple.

As if in retaliation her hand finally found its way to my crotch and started to rub my now stiff rod inside my jeans. I moaned in return and squeezed her tit a little harder. With my other hand I started trying to slip inside her tight shorts to get hold of her ass. But I was stopped when Beth called “time!”

Susie and I slowly broke away from each other with a look in each other's eyes that said this wasn’t the end of it. I half-crawled back to my recliner due to the tightness in my jeans caused by my throbbing cock. The girls were all giggling as I finally sat down.

“Wow, you two sure are making it hot in here,” Beth laughed waving her hand in front of her face as if trying to cool off. “So you able to make your next pick now, David, or do you need more time to recover?”

“Hey, I’m just playing the game,” I defended myself. “I don’t want to be accused of not fulfilling my dare. So, anyway, let me think here…. Hmmm, I’d like to pick Beth to get back at you, but that’s against the rules. Hmmm….”