Yes, you tie and fuck her.

You grab Lilly's arms hard enough for her to feel the pressure, but not enough to bruise. You take the belt and tie it just above her elbows.

She was expecting you to tie her wrists, so why not keep her guessing?

You give her ass a light, but firm push. The naked girl ends up laying stomach and face first on the bed now.

She makes a show of wiggling her arms to 'try and get loose' as you take off your clothes.

"Please don't do this," she says in a faux terrified voice, "Don't fuck me with your big, hard cock. I can't take something that big."

You ignore her fake pleas for help and push your cock into her moist pussy. She's wetter than you expected.

Deep down, she must have known that you'd save her and got all wet. Otherwise...best not to think about it.

You start to fuck her after little hesitation, knowing that she is good to go!

She moans 'against her will' as you take her.

To aid in your fucking, you grab the belt tied around her arms for more leverage.

You also start to spank her!

After she cums twice, you pull out and slap her ass with your dick.

"I'll give you two choices.

One- I take your ass right now in this position.
Two- you ride me, but I take your pussy. Decide quickly."