Yes, more thoroughly than hoped

“I'll do it, so just shut up!”, she exclaimed more confidently than she felt about it. “Atta girl!”, Sarah cheered and even though the rest of the group wasn't that outspoken there was a sense of relief and excitement that the game would go on. If Nicole had any hopes of a last second rescue from one of the guys, it was thoroughly dashed.

“Despite all the dissing, I'm a really a nice guy. See, let me make it easier for you”, Tom offered in a a mocking voice while he unbuttoned the top button of his jeans, apparently in anticipation of her hand exploring the insides of his pants very soon. “Thank you so much!”, Nicole replied dripping with sarcasm but she fell silent quickly after once she had to focus on the task ahead. For a moment she had considered if she could get away with just feeling it over his jeans, but his action just then made it clear that he would call her out on it and even without looking at the others she knew no one would side with her.

Slowly she took two steps towards the taller and muscular boy she despised, closing the space between them she had intentionally left open before. She felt like a a sheep led to the slaughter as Tom looked down on her with that annoying arrogant grin. It didn't help that her breasts were half exposed and perfectly on display for him neither. “Come on, don't make such a big fuss out of it, it only gives him more satisfaction”, she chided herself and with only slight hesitation moved her hand towards his waist until she touched his stomach and then let it slip downwards into his pants. The easier path would have been sliding along his stomach, but she took great care to not miss the spot where his boxers started and keep them between her hand and Tom's dick, saving her from direct contact with it.

If he was bothered by it, he didn't let it show though: “There you go, pumpkin. Like feeling my cock? Don't be shy, you can admit it. All the bitches love it”, he taunted in a whisper only audible to her. “Asshole”, she hissed back. But she did feel it. The bulge under her fingers. It was softer than expected, so she knew he wasn't even entirely hard yet. Despite her dare being to find out how big he was, there was no way she could give a good guess, really. Her mind was too busy trying process what she was doing and she didn't exactly had a lot of experience in that area neither. But she decided that it was sure good enough to complete the dare and without looking at Tom started to pull out her hand again.

A nice guy would have been disappointed about that short experience. But Tom surely wasn't a nice guy. With his back towards the rest of the group and a good distance between them, neither of the others could actually see what exactly was going on. Right when Nicole's hand left his pants he grabbed her arm and without giving her time to react forceful shoved her hand back into his pants. “Oh no bitch, you aren't finished here yet. You haven't even felt how big it gets yet.”, he jeered. His voice low to not alert the others but malicious and dominating. If someone had asked her before how she would react to it, she would have eagerly described the slap into the face she would have given. But instead she just stood there shocked. Shocked that Tom spoke to her and treated her this way in front of her friends, shocked that she had been stupid enough to let herself be goaded into such a position to begin with. But mostly shocked that her hand was now in direct contact with the skin of his penis as his unexpected shove didn't leave her time to keep his boxers in between.

The heat of his shaft was emanating through her fingers. It was more imagination than reality of course, but she felt like it nearly burned her. And she still couldn't believe she was standing here, in front of Tom, her chest half naked and her hand on his dick. It grew. It took her a moment to realize, but there was no mistaking, every heartbeat it became a bit harder, hotter and bigger. "Am I causing that?", she wondered and out of reflex she looked up questioningly into Tom's eyes, only to find his lecherous gaze shifting between her breasts and her face. But she stood there frozen in place as seconds ticked by and it still grew in her hand. The shock and disgust partly gave way to surprise. “Ohmygod. What the hell is wrong with him? It's huge...”, an unwanted thought went through her mind.

Tom, sensing her inability to stop him and not missing any opportunity put his hand on his jeans, right were her much smaller hand was inside and grabbed, causing Nicole to grab too and feel his hard shaft even closer pressed against her fingers. An upward motion with his hip made it perfect – for him – letting her delicate hand glide along his shaft as he basically started to jerk himself off on her. It only lasted for two “strokes” though before Nicole's mind snapped back into place. “What the fuck am I doing?!”, she yelled in her thoughts and as if to make up for her passivity before pulled her hand out of his jeans with such a momentum that she lost balance, stumbled backwards and landed on her ass, right in front of Tom.

“Everything okay there?”, John asked with a mix of worry and curiosity. “Yeah, don't worry. She was just surprised by my size. I get that reaction all the time”, Tom laughed while looking down on her. Nicole got back onto her feet, spat out a “Fuck off” and walked back towards the group. What else could she have said “I accidentally jerked him off but was too dumb to stop him or say anything?”. She didn't even understand herself why she let that happen and why she had allowed him to talk to her that way. While in thought she unwittingly wiped her hand on her pants, leaving a small stain of Tom's precum, an action which no one except Tom noticed.

“So? Come on girl, out with it! Is he hung?”, Sarah inquired with excitement and curiosity once everyone had sat back down. “He has a tiny dick, could hardly find it”, Nicole replied in a flat voice drawing laughter from everyone but Tom. However, he didn't even seem to be bothered by it, instead he just spread his legs, “manspreading” on his chair in front of the group, putting the bulge on display. Sarah eyed it for a second, then turned to Nicole: “Wow, girl you really got him excited eh? You sure about that size though? It was part of the dare so if you lie it means you forfeit.”. “After all that hard work”, Tom added with his typical half arrogant half jovial tone.

“Fine. Yeah the rumor is true, his dick his huge. Petty sure bigger than you guys”, she blurted out with a quick side glance towards John and Matt, instantly regretting it. Why the hell had she said that? She didn't even know. She was a bit angry with John and Matt for allowing Tom to go through with it but her stab just made Tom look better and her sound like a slut. Her face was red from blushing again and eager to just take the attention away from her she soldered on: “He's still a fucking asshole I wouldn't be caught dead hanging out with. Now it's my turn to draw. Pass over the hat!”