Would you?

My brow furrowed at the strange email, and I wracked my brain to try and think about who I’d fucked junior year. All this did was bring a smile to my face as I recalled the many conquests I’d had that year. Not even the lies she quoted helped me narrow it down, since I spouted them often, but it didn’t really matter since this was clearly a nonsense email from some dumb bitch who was trying to pretend she was too pure to put out without some big conspiracy.

Before I could really think further on this, a knock came at my door followed by the excited exclamations demanding I let them in. My mouth parted in a big smile as my frat brothers piled into my apartment, each holding either a bottle of liquor or case of beer. Without skipping a beat we had a game of pong going and music blasting on my speakers. Before I moved in I had made sure to double check that all the tenants were chill and young so there wouldn’t be any noise complaints, meaning we were free to be loud and have some fun!

I was 3-0 by the time the chicks showed up and more than a few shots in. We all offered them a hello as I took them all in. The only one I knew before tonight was Cindy. I’d never fucked her cause she’s one of the bros, but I’d be lying if I said she want hot as fuck. She is 5 foot 9, she spent most of her free time swimming, and it showed, and had long blonde hair and blue eyes. Her best attributes though were her massive d cups and big ass, both of which were big but perky. The girls she brought were pretty good looking too to be fair, but not quite her. The first of the two, introduced as Cat, is around 5 foot 7, a kind of pixie cut going with her brown hair which did frame her face nicely, and brown eyes. She seemed like she was in decent shape, but her tits weren’t that big and she wasn’t a stunner so. I found myself disappointed in her.

Finally, there was Marcy. She wasn’t hot, but the cutest girl ever. She was only like 5 foot 3, very petite but with big b or c cups that looked so much bigger in her. She had brown hair, which normally wasn’t my style, but had big hazel eyes and a way of shyly biting her bottom lip that just screamed corrupt me...and that was the plan. I immediately abandoned the game with my friends and struck up a conversation with Marcy. She seemed shy at first, only giving short answers and not meeting my eyes, but since I was turning up the charming nice guy energy, she soon opened up.

We were on the couch and talking after awhile and I asked, “So Marcy, what’s a nice girl like you doing with cindy and my degenerate friends?”

She laughed and playfully hit my arm as she said, “haha I know, but I like Cindy and even though I’m different than her I still like hanging out with her.”

“Different how?” I asked as if this were the most interesting conversation I’d ever had, which obviously it wasn’t but I wanted this girl.

With a sigh she said, “Well I had a bad experience with a guy when I was younger, so I’m not as...sexual I guess, as Cindy and them. Not that I judge of course! That’s just me.”

I tried hard to keep the grin off my face as I saw the in I’d been waiting for...