Woken up by a surprise

Dreams of Carolyn's double blowjob dance in your head until you wake up to a mouth on your organ. You reach out and caress Carolyn's boob as she blows you again. As she feels you touch her, she stops and moves up to kiss you, laying on top of your body. Her mouth is soft and sweet-tasting. Her tits feel great pressing into your muscled chest.

She breaks the kiss and whispers, "Thank you for last night. That was the most amazing night of my life. I want you and John to do that to me again and again. It wasn't too weird fucking me with your best friend, was it?"

"No," you whisper. "It felt very natural. I wasn't the slightest bit self-conscious. Fucking you with John was the highlight of my life too. I'm glad you want us again."

"I more than want you again. I have an unusual request," she whispers. You sense from her voice that she's scared.

"What is it? You sound scared," you ask, concern coloring your tone.

"I am scared. What if this ruins everything? Jack, I want to be both your girlfriend, slut, playtoy, whatever, as well as John's. I want you both. Do you think you can share me and not fight over me?"

Now you're scared. That is a very unusual request. Thinking about it, you think that you and John could share Carolyn without fighting. You just did, didn't you? But long-term is harder. "You want to make the three of us a permanent arrangement? Like date as a threesome, not just sex?"

"Yup. I want both of you to be a part of my life. We wouldn't always have to be the three of us. But plenty of three-way dates and late night escapades. I think that's the real meaning of 'ménage à trois'. I've been reading Anais Nin."

"Yes."

"'Yes' what?" she asks.

"Yes, I want to be with you, however I can. If that means sharing you with John, so be it."

Carolyn squeals quietly and you can see her smile in the light coming in the window from the street. "I haven't asked John, but I think he'll say 'yes'."

"What if he doesn't agree?" Now you're a little worried.

"Well, there's still us. You agreed to share with him, so if he says 'no', it's his loss for being inflexible. Now, are you sure you want to do this? People at school may think it's too weird."

"I don't care what the jerks at school think. I care what you and John think."

"Thank you, Jack." She kisses you and rubs her body all over you. You roll away from John's sleeping form and pin Carolyn under you, holding her arms over her head. She wraps her legs around you, and you slide your stiffness right into her slippery cunt.

You realize this is the first time you've fucked Carolyn alone. You want to finish this alone, so you capture her lips in a deep kiss as you thrust hard and fast inside her. In a minute, she's moaning and shrieking into your mouth, and her pussy muscles are squeezing you tight. You pound her for another couple minutes as her orgasms bloom and fade several times.

Finally, you erupt, sending what seems like an endless supply of cum deep inside Carolyn's well-fucked cunt. Your roars of triumph are muffled in her mouth. You are really tired from fucking all night, and you roll a little to let Carolyn out from under you. Then you fall fast asleep.