Wedding plans?

After that remark, you have an idea come to you. "You know, even though he is your pet, you could still marry him, you know."

Bethany scoffs at that suggestion. "Why? Like I said, it's not like I don't love him."

"Are you sure? I mean, you did call him your pet. I had a dog when I was younger, and even though it was different, I still loved him. And besides, you said that, to everyone else, he's your boyfriend, and that's just for show. So why not make him your husband for show? Besides, it would make a much better cover for the sisterhood. No one would suggest that you were a member of a supernatural magical feminist organization if you got married."

Bethany is very surprised and pleased by your reasoning. It all makes perfect sense. "You know, Valerie, you're right. That's the wonderful thing about bringing in new sisters. When a new woman joins, you never know what new wisdom she'll bring to the sisterhood. All right, we'll do it. The wedding is on!"

"Can I still play with him once in a while?"

"Of course you can!"

At the same time, Bethany's reference to you using feminine pronouns and her offering to let you play with Paul once again makes you keenly aware of your new womanhood and your new feminine identity. It gives you a slight feeling of pleasure inside.