Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 5 by whatsawhizzer whatsawhizzer

What do you do next?

Watch Quietly

If you were just having fun, and someone barged in on you that would so embarrassing! You decide that it is way safer to sit back and watch than try to interrupt. You put the knife aside for a bit. You don’t really have it in you to attack someone with a knife anyway.

The pretend **** now has large chunks of the woman’s hair in his grip. He is pulling her head up and down his cock in rapid thrusts, fucking her mouth like he might fuck her pussy. She keeps gagging and ****, but every time she tries to pull away, he shoves even harder.

She keeps making deep throaty sounds every time he strikes the back of her throat, and you wonder if it’s supposed to be a moan. Her makeup is completely destroyed, her hair is all over and tangled, and tears continue to stream down her face, but still he doesn’t let up, roughly fucking her.

He lets out his own gasps with each thrust, and if you weren’t certain this was role play before, you’re pretty sure now. All it would take is a little teeth to turn this situation grim, but she is quite careful to keep her throat quite open for his penetrations. You’re surprised that she’s able to take it without throwing up, considering how brutal it is, but you supposed if this is her kink, she’s gotten used to it.

Finally, he pulls out of her mouth, long streams of saliva and pre-cum between her mouth and his dick. She lets out a shuttering gasp that turns into a cough, and he seems to give her a moment or two to recover. She’s on the ground, taking deep, painful breaths.

“Is… is that good enough?” She begs, but the expression on her face looks more excited than scared.

“Get on the bed.” He barks.

Her eyes twinkle a bit, but she puts on a look or abject terror, “No please! I’m a virgin!”

You roll your eyes. If that girls a virgin, you’re a princess. You start to relax a bit, allowing yourself to enjoy the show. In some ways, it feels like watching a b-rated movie, although you couldn’t decide which had less tits in it.

She moves onto the bed, hiking up her torn red dress and immediately spreading herself open for him in a very un-virgin like way. She’s wearing lacy red underwear that is practically see-through, but she moves it to the side so he can have access.

He kneels between her legs, reach a hand out and grabbing her underwear roughly and pulling it. The straps come up and you hear a tearing sound, although he doesn’t seem to get it off of her. Instead, it just causes the underwear to wedge up her butt crack, and giving her a gasp. Her mouth barely quirks a smile, almost breaking the character of the scared, **** girl.

The **** slaps her in the face, as if to remind her he’s in charge, then reaches down with his other hand and pulls again. The fabric tears a little more, and keeps ripping at the thin fabric until it’s in shreds. For a semi-seethrough piece of fabric, it was surprisingly resilient.

He then reaches forward and pulled her dress. It ripped far more favorably, tearing apart in a quick and satisfying motion that seemed to even surprise him. She gasped as her entire body became exposed and naked, except the tattered remains of her underwear, which looked more like holy fishnets at this point.

The man slammed his dick into her immediately. She puts on a smile, pleasure flooding in her face. Then, as if she suddenly realized that she was ruining the mood, her face changed to a look of abject horror and pain.

“Oh!” She cried. “It’s so big! That hurts.”

You almost snort at that, but even though you know it’s fake, it’s still turning you the hell on.

“Oh yeah!” The guy chuckles darkly, fully in character, “You’re so wet, you little slut, you know you want this.”

“No, please, stop!” The girl protested. “I don’t want to get pregnant.”

The guy ignored her please and began thrust into her. They were rough thrusts, disorderly and random, like he was trying to open her up as wide as possible with his dick my thrust in each and every direction. She let out soft moans and whimpers, the tears starting to flow down her face once again.

He continued to thrust into her, over and over again, occasionally grabbing a nipple and twisting it roughly, or giving her a slap on the face as if to remind her to cry.

“Now that I’ve taken your virgin pussy, I think it’s time to take your virgin asshole!” The man declares, pulling out of her.

“Wait… not-“

The girl started to say something, but he puts a hand over her mouth and then sticks his dick into her ass in a single swift motion, using the slickness of his dick and her pussy juices to slide it in. She let out a screech, and for the first time you think the pain on her face is actually genuine. If there was a script they were following in doing all of this, he just left it.

She tried to reach down to grab his dick, but he slapped her hands away roughly and begins pushing it in and out of her butt.

She lets out a cry. “Ow, that hurts.”

“You bet it does, you dirty slut.” The guy laughs. “And once I’ve fucked your ass I’m going to make you eat my dick until I cum. And if you’re a good girl, maybe I’ll let you off with just that.”

The girl looks pained, but she gives a grimacing nod of acceptance, tears welling up in her eyes. He continues to slide in and out of her, and after a while, he sticks two fingers into her and starts fucking her with his hand.

Little by little, the pain starts to lesson in her face, and she starts to genuinely moan. She lifts her neck a bit, and he reaches up and grabs it.

He starts thrusting into her harder and harder. At some point it falls out of her butt, and he slams it right back into her pussy, being far wetter and more lubricated at this point. Faster and faster he rams his dick into her, and as he goes, his hand starts tightening on her throat.

At first, she’s loving this, giving little moans and gasping breaths, but at a certain point she starts having trouble breathing. The man continues to tighten his grip, and her face starts to turn colors as his dick rams into her over and over again. She reaches her hands up and tries to grab his hand and pull it away, but he doesn’t respond. He seems to be deeply focused, his eyes staring into hers, he dick pounding into her. It’s almost like he’s pounding the life right of her.

You realize that this has officially gone on too far, and that you need to do something. You kick open the door and step forward.

“Hey, you’re killing her!” You shout.

The noise shocks the assaulter and he immediately let’s go, stumbling off of her like he was caught by a lover. His eyes seem to regain focus and he looks down at the girl under him. The color starts to return, but she’s not moving.

“Oh! Oh god!” he shouts, “I didn’t mean to, I just…”

The girl sits up and gives him a dirty glare, “In my ass? Without lube? How about I fuck you in the ass and see how you feel!”

She gets up, pulling a sheet with her and wrapping around herself. She doesn’t seem even remotely phased by the fact he was **** her practically ****! The man pulls of his mask and tosses it to the side, revealing a fairly handsome man with shaggy brown hair. He has a worried look on his face.

“How’s your neck?” You ask, trying to get her to focus on what’s important.

She glances you up and down before looking away with disinterest, “My neck’s fine. People have the best fucking orgasms when they’re asphyxiated.”

You blink at that… that can’t be true, can it? Even if it was true, it sounded like something pretty damn dangerous.

“But!” She shouts, turning back to him. “I don’t like you slipping it into any holes I don’t approve of, you stupid shit!”

The man blinks, “W-we didn’t agree on any specific holes. You said you wanted me to be rough and make you hurt. I just thought-“

“You thought?” the girl snapped. “And who gave you permission to think. You’re just some dumb guy… a dick for my pussy. All you have to do is stick it in and make me cum. How can you fuck that up?”

“I – I’m sorry.”

“Don’t be!” The girl closed her eyes and held up her hand dramatically as she pinches her nose. “I’ll let you off light today because I just had enough time to cum before this dumb twat came storming in. That dirty talk at the end was just enough… barely. So I’m good. See you around. I’m out of here.”

“What? But wait I…” the guy trailed off, his hand pointing at his still very much erect dick.

“Go finish yourself off in the bathroom, dumbass.” The girl scuffs, turning away from him and walking away. She brushes past you, bumping you out of her way as she goes, the sheet trailing behind her as she heads down the hall and stairway at the end.

You turn to the guy, who seems to have a surprised look on his face, just like you. You kind of feel bad for him. He was doing exactly what she asked, and yet she was going to walk off without a care. Still, he could really give a girl a ride for her money. Maybe you could take him where she left off? Maybe no chocking, but your definitely ready for some rough sex. You weren’t sure how you felt about getting anal though.

On the other hand, you see a strap-on sitting on one of the counters, probably one of her “toys”. Maybe you could teach him exactly what it’s like to get it in the ass.

What will you do?

More fun
Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)