Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 4 by Tinylittlecocked Tinylittlecocked

What does Jake choose?

To do what they say.

" fine, I'll do whatever you ask." Jake said, feeling completely defeated. "Good choice baby dick. I don't think you want anyone else knowing your tiny little secret." Gina said, clearly enjoying how humiliated Jake was.

" What should we do to him now?" Sarah asked. " I got it" Rachel said and ran inside. Rachel returned a minute later, with the 3 pillows from Jake's room.

Rachel tossed the pillows on the ground, then looked at Jake and said " climb on top. Fuck the pillows like crazy. Just like you did when you jerked off for us. The only thing is you're not going to stop having pillow sex for 30 minutes. We'll tell you when to stop."

Jake knew he had **** so he straddled the pillows. The pillows were extremely soft and There was a worm, slippery liquid on them. Rachel had microwaved a few bottles of lube, then dumped them on the pillow.

Jake couldn't control himself, as it was the best feeling, he had ever had from his little cock. The second Jake's dick touched the pillow,he started shaking and moaning uncontrollably. All the girls bursted out laughing at Jake again.

Jake thrusted himself around on the pillows, looking like a **** horny fool. Not even a minute after he climbed on the pillows, Jake started Cumming again. Jake started to slow down, but Rachel said "nope you're not done, keep going or we make sure your videos go viral"

Jake quickly started humping as fast as he could. Jake had no idea how pathetic he looked, as he pretty much was having sex with a pillow. All the girls couldn't contain their laughter, as they teased and filmed Jake making a fool out of himself.

Jake was so turned on he stopped paying attention to all the comments about him. Unfortunately, Jake didn't notice the 3 girls, around his age, see the commotion and start walking over to see what was going on.

It turns out it was Ava, Sofia and Erin, all girls that had gone to high school with Jake, Rachel, Sarah, Kate, Gina and Leah. Gina noticed then and said " hey girls, you remember us?" As she point to the rest of her friends. " Yes Gina we do, but who's that making a fool of himself?" Ava asked.

"It's that cocky bastard Jake, the guy who acted like a huge dick." Gina said and Ava answered "That's too funny. We hate that loser." Rachel walked over and said " well then you probably want to see how itty bitty his baby penis is"

Rachel pulled out her phone and showed the 3 girls that just walked up the pictures and videos they took of Jake. " This is perfect. It's what he deserves for how he acted in highschool." Ava said, then Gina added " yeah and we are no where near done with him and I got the perfect plan for what to do to him next."

What is Gina's plan?

More fun
Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)