Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 3 by FallenSaint FallenSaint

Who do you follow first?

Tila and the Young Man

Tila led her young stud into her chosen stall, purring happily and stripping her shirt off as they went. She had noticed the young man watching her ass and tail wiggle as she walked and was glad she didn't let Silvan talk her into wearing pants. She always liked when men and women looked at her ass. The young man introduced himself as Clayton Meyers, but she didn't care about that right now. Clayton stripped off his shirt and she let out a soft purr of delight. He was strongly built with muscular arms and six pack abs. Silvan was no slouch, more lean and sinew than muscle, thanks to years of hard travels. But it had been some time since she had fucked someone with muscles from hard work and tough living.

She stood on her tiptoes to reach him and brushed a kiss against his lips, making sure to purr once more as she slid down his chest, kissing and licking her way down. She stopped to give his nipples some attention with her tongue and purred again when he gave a throaty moan. She doubted he was a virgin, but such a small village had to have limited his choices. She might just be the hottest little piece of ass he ever got. That thought thrilled her a bit as she landed on her knees before him.

Clayton was already fighting with his belt, but she stopped him saying "Tonight, that's my job." He nodded dumbly as her agile little hands quickly slid his belt off of him with practiced ease and then began working his pants down. She took her time with it, making it go painfully slow, and stopped just before his cock could come free. She looked up into his eyes with a wicked smile and giggled when he moaned that she was a tease. She gave him a wink and then jerked his pants down to the floor. His cock was on par with Silvan's in a way. It wasn't as thick, but maybe an inch longer. She could enjoy herself with this.

He was already raging hard, and she was half tempted to jump straight into fucking, but she wanted to savor the moment while she could. Tila lowered her head and let her tongue swirl around the head of his cock while gently stroking it with one hand. After a few moments, she moved her hand down to play with his balls and began bobbing her head on his shaft. The head of his cock easily slid between her lips and she took half his length before pulling back and bobbing again. She could handle Silvan's length easily, so Clayton's wasn't a challenge, but she made a show of gagging on just half his length to make him feel special. He wasn't as smart as Silvan had been their first time, so Clayton didn't notice that she was faking and instead made some comment about how great his cock was. Silvan had caught her and **** her head down to take his whole shaft and she really had gagged then. After he had finished taming her, he had taught her to really handle a cock, so she never really gagged anymore.

So with Clayton being an easy mark, she set about her task and enjoyed herself. She made pitiful noises as she "gagged" and pretended that he was larger than life. The farm boy for his part moaned and called her amazing, but she knew she didn't need to suck him too long. If he blew in her mouth, she wasn't sure she could fuck him again without more money. Having to keep her desires in check was going to be hard. So she gave him a few more licks on the head of his shaft before settling back into the hay and reaching down to finger her little pussy.

"Oooh Clayton! Come give me your cream! Tila wants your big cock so baaaad!"

Clayton was on her in an instant and she gave a yelp as he knelt on her tail. He hurridly apologized as he pushed his cock into her, and it felt so good that she was incline to forgive him. He wasn't as practiced as Silvan, but he was enthusiastic. His quick and powerful pace soon had her moaning loudly. She could hear Mona across the room also getting into it, and the old man gasping for breath, but she didn't care how her companions were faring right then. Without thinking, she raked her nails down his back, and Clayton reared up in pain and pleasure as his cock shoved deep into her.

Suddenly he pulled out, leaving her panting and wondering why he stopped. She gave a pitiful mewl of desire and then realized what he intended. Clayton was realigning his cock with her tight little asshole now that he had lubricated it in her pussy. She liked anal, but her ass always remained so tight that she had to adjust to it before the pain stopped. And Clayton didn't know how easy he needed to push into her.

"Wait, you need to- MROOOOW!"

She wasn't able to warn him in time as he **** the first few inches of his cock into her. She threw her head back and moaned, writhing under his strong frame as inch after inch was fed into her until his bass rested against her ass. When he bottomed out, she was left panting and unable to speak, so Clayton began to saw his cock into her with almost the same speed he had done in her pussy. Pain overtook pleasure for a few moments until she managed to relax her muscles and let the pain fade. He was good, but she would need to be more careful about first timers taking her ass.

"Oooh damn kitten your ass feels good!"

"Fuck it Clayton! Fuck my ass harder," she moaned, so glad that Silvan had made her a whore. She loved her master, but getting sex like this every day was going to be great. Clayton picked up speed and soon was bucking his hips hard and fast, but with almost no control. She began teasing her clit as he pounded her with all his might and soon they both crashed through powerful orgasms that had them both crying out. Clayton pulled his still semi-hard cock from her ass and gave an approving smile as his seed began to leak from her.

Tila was more than willing to lay there and bask in the after glow of great sex, but she heard her beloved master returning. She hoped he had enjoyed himself as much as he had.

What happens Next?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)