Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 5 by Caelum83 Caelum83

That was great. Time to get some shut eyes.

There is still one female too hot and bothered to sleep.

Laying there for 5 minutes, Cindy still held on tightly and you still had your dick hanging out while your eyes rested on the sweet redhead and her exposed shoulders in front of you. Wait, was it just you or did your sister slowly move towards you. The next moment you were sure she did. Her little butt carefully nudged against your crotch as if it was searching for something, then as she felt his cock, Chrissy softly grinded into his dick with long movements. “Uhhhhhh.” you grunted, making her stop instantly. When you didn’t complain or object, her butt started to rub your cock again through her panty fabric. Slowly she felt your dick stiffening up again. The importance of her working on you didn’t really register until she stopped rubbing and pulled down her her panties, leaving your cock to feel her naked asscheeks against your dick. “Sis…” you whispered confused. Then you felt the blanket rose a bit and a hand from between her legs grabbed your hard cock. You felt the girl shift her ass up as the hand guided your cock to a wet, little slit. “Chrissy!” you whispered loudly. You got no response while the girl kept trying to softly make you pop inside her tight slit. You had the hardest time trying to think of doing the right thing, let alone do the right thing as you whispered urgently “Chris, what are you doing?!? You are my sister!”. In response you heard her soft voice reply in “Not now, brother. Please don’t talk until it’s done, ok?”. You looked perplexed. Did your little baby sister just told you to shut up until you had fucked her?

In the meanwhile you felt your cock slowly sank into the tightest pussy you had ever been in. As it did, you also heard your baby sister moan for the first time. You were speechless, you just made your sister moan out of horniness as her pussy was wrapped around your cock. In all these years seeing her naked, never once would you have thought your cock would plunge into her honeypot. Never once would you have thought the mouth that constantly bitch to you and talk to you about brotherly stuff would moan for you. It was a sound that would only emit from her if she was with her boyfriends and you didn’t need to be there to hear it. Now it was as if you heard a forbidden sound. As she slowly pushed back she put her hand behind her on your hip and urged you to fuck her too. You shoved one hand under her hip and grabbed her there, your other hand slid up her hip to her armpit and over her bikiniclad titties.

“One sec…” she softly said and undid her bikinitop, but you mistook her and stopped penetrating her. Having her hands over her now unclasped bikini covered breasts, she looked back and said “You didn’t have to stop fucking me.”. As you resumed fucking your sister she looked forward and breathed “Idiot…”. You smiled. THAT was your sister. She pulled out her bikini top from under the blanket and threw it in a corner, then reached down as you continued pushing up your dick inside her cunt and grabbed her bikini bottom, wanting to throw that away too. But you grabbed it out of her hands just as it rose up under the blanket and had to sniff your sister. You noticed a huge wet spot at the front of it. Could it be she knew you had fucked Cindy just now? Without warning a hand from behind him crawled under his arm and softly grabbed and massaged Chrissy’s now exposed titty. And in your ear you heard Cindy whisper “Is she tight? Is she wet?” while Cindy pushed her crotch up against your butt every time you slid inside your sister.

“C-c-cindy?” you stammered softly. “Uhummm.” she whispered acknowledging in your ear. “She was rubbing herself fervently when you screwed me, but couldn’t get off when we did.” Cindy explained softly, listening to the soft wet slaps of her boyfriend and his sister copulating while hearing Chrissy’s lewd cries when your dick pushed deep inside of her. “So I ask you again. Is she tight? Is she wet?” Cindy asked. You laughed softly and replied “I didn’t knew you had such a dominating part inside of you.”. Cindy’s voice got a little serious as she said “Listen, you are fucking your own sister, without condom. If you don’t want anyone to find out about this, you’d better stop speaking up and start answering questions.”. Impressed by her sudden change of character, you answered obediently “She is fucking tight and dripping wet.”. Satisfied, Cindy slapped your ass.

Chrissy moaned as she heard you talking about her tight cunt and how wet she was. She was superhorny from the fact that she was fucked from behind by her own brother in a tent in the middle of nowhere while his girlfriend watched. Cindy though, thought that things could get a bit more kinky, just to complete the experience and pulled the blanket off them and down to the foot end. “This will not do.” she said “This girl is in dire need of some proper fucking this weekend and you will give just that to your little sister and show her how dear she is.” Cindy said as she pulled Chrissy to her knees. As she got close to Chrissy, their boobs touched each other and she softly asked while kneeding and pinching the younger girl’s tits “So, dear sexy, horny, lustfull little Chrissy, what is your favorite posh?”. Chrissy responded with “I ...ahhhh....I like to-aahhhh...to fuck-ahhh...ouch….fuck….on to-AAHHHhhhh….top. Fuck on top! Aahhhh…” while continuously getting her nipples pinched or her tits softly slapped. Cindy looked into Chrissy's eyes and said to you “Mmmmm, a girl that wants to be in control, I like your sister. Roll over on your back.”.

Then she grabbed your sister’s hands and guided her until Chrissy straddled you, while keeping eye contact with her. Cindy crawled close behind Chrissy, your girlfriend’s breasts flattened against your sister’s back. She slowly put her chin on your sister’s shoulder, while Chrissy, a bit intimidated by your girl and the situation, shyly looked at your chest. “Look at him.” Cindy whispered in her ear “Chrissy, look your brother in the eyes.”. Chrissy complied and looked straight at you. You saw anxiety, need, doubt, lust, shame, excitement, sisterly love, all mixed in together. “He is your brother, your blood.” Cindy continued, softly tracing lines over Chrissy’s soft skin, leaving your sister breathless. “What you are about to do is taboo, perverted.” your girlfriend whispered in your sister’s ear. You saw the struggle in your sister’s eyes. “If you let him inside you unprotected,…” Cindy said while her hand rubbed over Chrissy’s mount and then slid her middle finger in, making Chrissy gasp, “...you got a good chance he will impregnate you.”. Chrissy’s doubt, but also her lust, rose higher. “Are you willing to take that chance over a meaningless taboo fucking session?” Cindy purred, still feeding Chrissy’s lust by working on your sister’s cunt.

You could see that whatever doubt there was in Chrissy’s head, Cindy had her wrapped around her finger. Not in the least in the literal way, Chrissy’s hips following Cindy’s finger a like a puppy, craving the older girl’s touch to her sensitive pussy. Chrissy nodded feverishly. Cindy whispered “I want to hear you say it.” while she grabbed your dick from between Chrissy’s legs and rubbed it past Chrissy’s little lips. “Say it.” Cindy whispered again. Chrissy then softly but strictly said “I want to take my brother’s big dick and shove it into my incestuous pussy. I don’t care right now, I want to get fucked by my brother like the perverted little slut I am now. I am so horny right now, that the fact of getting knocked up by my big brother, makes me want to fuck him and cum on his dick even more.”. Cindy reveled in how incredibly horny your little sister was, which you could see in your girl’s eyes. She cupped Chrissy’s cunt with her free hand and helped guiding her other hand with sliding in your cock inside your anxious sister. Slowly, Chrissy rose up, then as your cock found it’s mark, it popped in and your sister slowly eased back down.

Bit by bit your dick crawled back into the tight little wet cleft of your sister, this time feeling very consciously doing so while Chrissie and you looked at each other. Cindy got more horny by the minute and whispered to you both “Even though she looked great in her bikini, she looks fucking hot in the nude, doesn’t she?”. You nod. “Compliment her on her sexy body.” Cindy ordered. You obeyed directly as you looked in the eyes of your dear baby sister of whom you never looked at her body as a sex object “Chris, your body looks awesome. Your tits are so soft and juicy, hanging perfectly. Your soft curvy hips look superb. Your vagina looks delicious and feels so good around my dick. And your eyes...” making Chrissy look away for a sec as they trembled “...those beautiful big eyes of the girl that is both my best friend and my little sis.”. Nobody noticed because it was so dark, but Chrissy blushed heavily. None of her boyfriends ever said anything like this about her and the intimacy of the moment, combined with these kinds of compliments regarding her own naked self, she couldn’t care less if what they were about to do was wrong. It felt so right, that her body moved on it’s own when she leaned forward, put her hands on your chest and kissed you passionately.

You knew these wet lips from many kisses between the two of you on your birthdays, when your team won the soccer competition and other such event. And it started as such a kiss, only this time your hardon was lodged deep inside her belly. Soon after though, you felt her tongue trying to gain entry to your mouth. If you let her, friendly kisses between siblings would never be the same. But you felt the importance of her getting her tongue inside your mouth as if it was proof of acceptance that not only this kiss, but this whole indecent mating she was initiating was mutually agreed to. After really trying, her tongue started to shy away from your closed lips disappointingly as if her fear of non-acceptance became reality, her lips slowly leaving your mouth, but then you quickly opened your mouth, moved your head up so that your lips firmly pressed into hers and grabbed the point of her tongue with them, sucking it in your mouth.

Her eyes shot open as you grabbed her behind her head and intimately started you kiss her. Her body became as putty and you felt it slowly relax against yours, her hard nipples of her firm breasts pressing into your chest. Drool lingered between your tongues as Chrissy slurpy whispered between kisses “Take…..me,....brother…..Fuck...your...little...sister.”. With your left hand still on her head, keeping her kissing you, your other hand slid down her back, over the small of it and landed on her soft, silky butt, just before she felt you push up inside of her. “Finally….” you heard her whisper as she started to breath heavily between kisses. You slowly fucked her, taking all the time of the world. You noticed that you found the intimacy and knowing your sister so good and for like her whole life make for a good feeling during sex. So different than the excitement of the unknown you had with other girls. You cuddled with your sister before, when one of you had something to cry over and none of you were shy to the intimacy it brought. Being in such close embrace with her, even with her naked skin touching you and being connected at the hip, sharing each other's sexual desires, it felt good. Different, but good.

In fact, you couldn’t get closer in their relationship than this. On the other hand, what would be left of your old relationship after this? Your doubts were instantly dismissed as Chrissy momentarily stopped kissing you and giggled happily “Hihihihi, ahhhhh, brother, it feels so good having you inside me. I know this is sooooo wrong…..ahhhhh….but it feels sooooo right.” she purred as she held your face and looked into your eyes. “Thank you!” she said with a smile on her face, which cringed a bit every time you hit home, and tears welling in her eyes. “I love you, brother.” she suddenly said. And sure, she used to say that occasionally in the past, but the intensity on her face pointed to that other kind of love. Surprise was written on your face and your sister saw that too, making her doubt she should have said those words. Looking down and away a bit she stammered softly “I-I-I….I’m s----?!?” until you put your finger on her lips, silencing her as she looked back at you again. Her questioning look, your finger silencing her, her breast still rocking as you kept on slowly fucking her, it was a mix of different kinds of intimacies all together. But Chrissy putting herself in such a **** state, exposing herself both figuratively and literally, you couldn’t do anything but smile and said “I love you too Chrissy”.

Then you heard a grunt from your right, where you saw Cindy with her legs spread as she pleasured herself over your indecent intimacy, now looking away as if she felt unwanted and set aside for a new girl. “Though I can’t stop loving Cindy either. Two beautiful and loving girls. I hope I don’t have to choose.” you thought out loud. Cindy looked back at you, smiled and crawled over to you, making Chrissy sit up straight, curiously looking at her. As Cindy looked at your dick sliding into your sister’s cunt, she said “Maybe we can remedy that dilemma.” and pulled up a leg, then straddled you face. You, not one to disappoint your girlfriend, wasted no time to bury your mouth in her cunt, making her purr contently. Cindy mewled as she looked Chrissy in the eyes, then leaned forward and held her left hand to your sister’s cheek. “Think you could love me too?” she breathed.

At first, Chrissy looked surprised. She never thought about doing it with another woman, let alone having feelings for someone of her own sex. But then she took in Cindy’s naked, sweat covered body, with her big tits pointing straight at her and her lustful gaze and automatically leaned in, suddenly very curious how woman taste like. You only saw a pair of asschecks from where you were lying, but you definitely heard your girlfriend make out with your sister and the thought of it alone got you even harder. “Mmmmmmm, your sister’s kisses taste sweet, darling.” Cindy purred “Maybe I should switch to dating the other sibling.”. Those words made Chrissy’s eyes shot open wide and made her blush. Then as Cindy grabbed Chrissy’s boob and softly kneaded it, she continued “Or maybe you two allow me to date you both?”. The thought of sharing your girlfriend with your sister first was an unpleasant one, but then it occured to you that Cindy effectively approved of your love for your sister and wanted to explore this route of a three way love without putting anyone on the sideline.

With so many new thoughts and experiences swirling through Chrissy’s head, it was hard for her to come to a decision. First, she let her brother cover her, then she made out with his girlfriend and now she was invited in a shared relation with them both, providing her a chance at exploring a lesbian relation next to fucking cock. Changing her relationship status to “It’s complicated” didn’t cover it at all. But her brother completely understood and loved her, Cindy was awesome and looked gorgeous and her current boyfriend rather would hang with his mates than with her. So when you put up your hand towards Chrissy for a high five, Chrissy slapped it with her own hand. “Yeeeeey” Cindy softly cheered with a smile. “This calls for a celebratory kiss and since your brother already got his mouth on my lower lips, my upper lips are all yours, my lover girl.” she said as she bend towards Chrissy. Chrissy complied and they both let their tongues play in each other’s mouth, while their moans vibrated against each other.

Their eyes locking from time to time, Cindy saw Chrissy slowly felt her orgasm ramp up and smiled “Don’t stop now, honey.” she said to you “Our sister is almost going to come.”. Cindy scooted forward off your face and planted her wet cunt on your belly, hugging your sister, tits rubbing together sensually, while the girls resumed their make out session. You grabbed Cindy’s hips as you kept on pumping yours upwards, hearing your sister moaning louder and louder into Cindy’s mouth. Cindy released Chrissy’s mouth from her own and while Chrissy now moaned loudly in the tent, anxiously looking forward to the sweet release of her orgasm, their eyes kept locked to each other with Cindy encouraging her “That’s it, baby. Cum for me. Ride that big dick like a real cowgirl. You can feel his cock trying to punch through your cervix, don’t you. Let’s see if your brother can knock you up.”.

Cindy’s hand reached for Chrissy’s clit and quickly rubbed it for her as she softly whispered “Come on. Come on. Come, baby. Cum for me. Cum for Cindy. Come on. You can do it. Cum hard for me. Come, baby.” while Chrissy was now edging her orgasm. Then Cindy slapped against your side and said “Knock up your sister, babe, cum deep inside her!” and as if on command , you subconsciously pictured your sister with a thick belly on the couch at your home and you felt your cock twitch inside your sister, firing fresh seed from your balls deep inside your younger sibling. Chrissy’s breath stocked in her throat as the pervertedness of you really had gone and shot your sperm deep inside her belly pushed her over the edge. While Cindy kept rubbing her spasming cunt, she asked Chrissy “Are you cumming, sweety?” to which she nodded fast. Cindy continued “Did he come deep inside you? Did my baby fire his babymakers deep inside you?” to which Chrissy heavily nodded. “That’s a good girl.” Cindy purred and started to kiss Chrissy on the cheek and worked her way down to her neck, while you couldn’t stop involuntarily pushing up your hips up into your sister’s.

After a bit you and your sister finally settled down, while Cindy kept kissing and sucking on Chrissy’s body, making her way to her firm tits, which made Chrissy shudder softly. Cindy moved back up and looked Chrissy in the eyes, whispering to her “Now we both carry his semen.”. Cindy gently pushed Chrissy off your now limb cock and rolled her sideways on her back and climbed on top of your sister. “I wonder if he hit the target, knocked one up, put a bun in the oven, so to speak with any of us two. Would be nice if he hit two times tonight wouldn’t it?” Cindy softly said to Chrissy with her mouth close to hers, her eyes rapidly switching between both Chrissy’s eyes and her mouth, seeing Chrissy’s eyes slowly closing and then kissed her deeply on the mouth. “Sleep tight, my love.” Cindy whispered to your sister. Before long, Cindy slid a bit to the right, between Chrissy and you and fell asleep too, still hugging Chrissy. You gently rolled to Cindy and spooned her with one arm around her waist, whispering “Sleep well, both of you.” and fell asleep with a smile on your face thinking about the good things that were yet to come.

The end

More fun
Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)