The old you back

"Simple, I want the old you back. The insatiable slut who wouldn't let herself be confined to some outdated sense of monogamy," Nicole says as she moves closer. "I knew she wasn't far from the surface." She walks over to Robert, reaching down to take his cock in hand. She makes a pleased little noise at the feeling of your cum around his dick as she strokes him. "Robert and I have been regular fuck buddies for awhile now. A young, assertive stud like him was exactly what I knew you needed to awaken that side of you again."

"It was my pleasure," Robert says with a smirk.

"I..I can't," you try and protest.

"Katherine, you already have. Robert here awoke that side of you. It's not going to keep quiet just because you say so," Nicole informs.

"But..I love James," you say, trying to put some steel in your voice.

"And I love Arthur. Sex and love aren't the same thing, Katherine," Nicole says matter-of-factly. "I have sex with other people. So does he. You could always give James the option to mess around." Nicole was continuing to stroke Robert's cock, its flaccidity starting to be waver as it harden again.

Your eyes widened at the sight, impressed and turned on by Robert's recovery time.

"See, that look right there. That's the real you, and it's nothing to be ashamed of! Sure us sluts have to "play the game" and act all prim and proper for polite society, but behind closed doors we can be who we really are," Nicole explains excitedly. "We let boytoys like Robert here have their fun, but we have the power. We're the ones that allow it. So like I said, let James fool around too." She grins wickedly. "Or you keep this grand life all to yourself. There's so much I could share with you."

You're about to speak. What exactly you don't know, but something, until Nicole interjects.

"Look, I'll prove you have a choice." She reached with her left hand, showing her phone. You gasp in horror when you realize she had recorded you. You were somewhere between despair and anger when Nicole then pressed a button. "See? Deleted. I got no interest in messing up your life, Katherine. Rather, I want you to live the best life you can."

By this point Robert was rock-hard again. In spite of the mix of emotions you're feeling, you find yourself looking back at it.

"It's real simple. You can walk out that door and back to a life you know you won't be satisfied with, or you can close it and join us for a raunchy threeway introduction into a freer life. What's it to be?" She asks, stepping away from the door, giving you ample opportunity to leave.