Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 3

What's next?

The morning after

James slowly opened his eyes. Feeling blissful and in love. He heard noise coming from the bathroom. Mary was up before he was it seemed. Beneath the blankets, he felt a mess of sticky fluids. He sighed, but smiled amusedly. He would have to clean that up. He thought of last night, remembering the feeling of incredible fullness his girlfriend had granted him. He felt his cock stiffen.

"You awake?" James heard. Mary's voice was gentle and still a bit shy. He turned his head and saw her stand in the doorway. Only reaching a bit over halfway.

"Mhm" James answered. But his eyes over her body. She was standing there completely naked. Her red hair hung down her shoulders. Her beautiful, big breasts pointed forwards. Leaning on one leg, she perfectly displayed her wide hips and thick glutes, though James did not know whether she had taken this stance out of comfort or whether it was an act of seduction. And my goodness, between her thick thighs hung her thick cock. She was entirely flaccid, but her big girl still reached down to her knee. It was an impressive, incredibly arousing sight. James felt his vastly inferior member jump happily in reaction to the sight of his girlfriend.

Mary walked over to the side of the bed, her heavy cock swinging from left to right with every short step she took. She blushed a little as she leaned in for a good-morning kiss.

"Good morning, big man." Mary said, giving James' abs a feel. She could feel her cock react. Thankfully it usually took a bit before it was hard due to its size.

"Good morning, beautiful" James responded, placing his hand against her face, controlling the kiss.

Then James reluctantly ended their kiss, got up and pulled away the blankets. Sitting on the edge of the bed, he was already towering over Mary. James pulled her in for another kiss, he let his hands slide over her body, not leaving her wide hips and big breasts untouched. Then he pulled away again.

"We should probably get cleaned up. I don't know about you but I'm kind of a mess." James said, ending his sentence in a chuckle.

Mary giggled. "Yeah probably." She laughed. "The bed seems to need a cleanup too."

James looked around and noticed several wet spots around the bed. One was definitely from his own cum, and the other was definitely caused by Mary's juices leaking from James' ass during the night.

"Yeah I noticed." James said, slightly amused." He looked back at Mary.

"I was thinking... maybe we could take a shower first?" Mary asked, her face turning red as if she was asking him out for the first time. She definitely had something else besides just showering in mind.

James caressed her face and kissed her shortly. "That sounds lovely, baby." He said. Mary returned the kiss and quickly squeezed James' cock. 'So cute!' She thought. Letting James' clearly visible excitement spike her own'. She broke the kiss and looked at his handsome face one last time before turning around and walking to the bathroom, leaving James behind on the bed.

"You coming?" She asked, turning around in the doorway. "Because I'm not going to figure out how your shower works." She said laughing.

James got up with a grin. Yes, showers in a strangers home usually did seem like spaceships and on top of that, James' bathroom was quite modern. He walked towards the bathroom door, where Mary had disappeared through a moment earlier. His small cock pointing upwards, tremoring with every step. He was no longer ashamed of it. Partly because his and his girlfriends' cocks were not even close to begin with, but mostly because the feeling of mutual love that they shared made him incredibly comfortable.

James stepped into the bathroom, and saw how Mary was taking a leak. She had simply laid her near-flaccid cock over the edge of the toilet seat, not being tall enough to do otherwise. She finished as James walked over, needing to take a piss himself. He had a hard time pointing his erect cock downwards, but he managed. As he finished up, he could feel a little hand run up his thigh and squeeze his ass. He turned and immediately felt Mary's lips eagerly wrap around his cock. Giving a quick suck and lick before she backed away with a smirk and stepped into the shower, her huge cock dangling as she went.

James followed her and eagerly. He loomed over Mary as he turned on the shower. As the warm water started rushing over them, James could feel Mary's lips wrap around his small member again. A tiny hand groped his balls gently. Her tongue drew circles around his glans as her lips reached the base of his penis. She was very good. But as James felt Mary's own, much larger cock, starting to rise, he realized that however good her blowjob was, this feeling was incomparable to the feeling that Mary's thick member had delivered him the night before. The same member that was now slowly twitching and pulsing in between his legs. The sheer girth of it made him weak in the knees again. He missed the incredible fullness in his ass. Wanting to experience that feeling again.

And so James got on his knees, face to face with his girlfriend, and kissed her as his hand started to slowly stroke Mary's massive beast.

"I want you to fuck me again, baby." James whispered in her ear, as he reached for a bottle of baby oil.

Mary smiled, breathing heavily as James pulled her against him. He felt her throbbing against his chest, leaking precum already. He let his head down a bit and decided to give it a taste. Mary gasped as she felt James' tongue eagerly lick the massive glans of her rod. James face was now buried between Mary's soft tits, for that was how far her erect cock reached now.

"Oh, James" Mary moaned. She had never experienced a blowjob before, and though she knew it was unlikely that James could fit it in his mouth, she greatly enjoyed his lips, tongue and saliva on her member.

James tried to take the head of Mary's monster into his mouth, but was instantly greeted with the impossibility of that task. Instead he took to slobbering and sucking on the tip. He cupped her balls as he suckled on her glans. They were heavy and warm and very much unlike his own balls. Meanwhile his own member was throbbing, nearly ready to cum. James noticed that just sucking on Mary's bigger cock, had his own little guy come really close to orgasming.

James then took the bottle of baby oil he had grabbed earlier, and spread a generous amount onto her cock, seeing that the warm water was constantly trying to wash her precum away.

Mary understood the assignment and helped James lower himself onto his back on the shower floor. As James pulled her on top of him, Mary's lubed up cock slid onto that of James, covering his smaller member under her massive girth. James cringed, almost cumming from that feeling alone. Mary noticed, the sight was both very endearing and exciting for her.

"Are you so close already?" She asked. There was no accusation in her voice, just amazement.

"From..." James felt a bit embarrassed to say it. So he simply looked down and caressed her long, thick shaft. "...this." Mary's eyes followed his down, then back up.

"You are this close from sucking me?" She asked excitedly.

James nodded, half of him was embarrassed to admit it, the other half was to horny to care.

"You must really like my big girlcock then, don't you? Mary said seductively, grinding her cock onto his while waiting for his answer.

"I- I love your girlcock." James answered, gasping at the mere sensation of feeling her cock. He was so close to cumming.

"You want it inside of you, baby?" Mary asked him teasingly. She had noticed his little star pucker at in anticipation. This time she did not wait for an answer however, and placed her tip at his bottom.

"Oh please, Mary!" James moaned.

Mary let out a girly moan as she slid in his tight hole, stretching him apart. Almost as soon as it popped past James' sphincter, the immensely thick head of her cock reached his prostate, pulsating against it. This sent James over the edge, cumming on nothing but the very tip of his girlfriends' dick. He let out a moan as his tiny cock shot out short ropes of cum onto his stomach.

"Oh, baby, that's so hot." Mary said. She pushed her cock further inside of James, leaning forward and licking his cum off his belly. She could hear James groan in pleasure above her as she managed to get almost her entire length inside of him. He felt so tight. So warm.

She placed her head on the lower part of James' ribcage and her hands on his hips as she started fucking him. Mary could now feel the vibrations of his moans in her head. It made her feel safe and comfortable. She hugged him tighter as she picked up the pace, causing James to cum again. Mary could feel his erection twitch in between both of their bellies.

James wrapped had his arms around his girl, and as he came, he wrapped his legs around her back. He kissed the top of her head, humming and moaning into her hair. James' ejaculate lubed up both of their bellies, causing them to rub onto each other more smoothly than before. Meanwhile, Mary's massive dick made a smacking sound every time she pulled away from his hole. Then with a 'smack' she would plant herself back inside of him to the hilt. Her thrusts were smooth, like a well oiled fucking machine. With every thrust, she rubbed her cock along James' prostate. This simulation was almost too much for James. The incredible girth of Mary's cock made him orgasm at least every minute.

"Oh I can feel you cumming against me." Mary moaned. She had closed her eyes, allowing to focus on all the sensations her body was experiencing.

"Oh baby I love your huge cock!" James moaned. His words excited Mary, making her cock twitch and throb inside of him as she kept thrusting. Hearing James talk dirty, she did the same, almost without thinking.

"Oh yeah you like my fat cock in your little butt?" She exclaimed. Hearing her girly voice saying these dirty things sent James over the edge once again, moaning an "Oh yes I do!" as he came.

"Oh yeah I can feel your little dick cumming baby-" Mary moaned in her horny, girly voice. Until she had noticed what she had just said. She stopped and looked up at him. "I'm sorry James, I-"

"It's okay sweetie." James said. "I know it is-"

"Its great!" Mary interrupted.

"But small." James finished.

"But I don't mind!" Mary said defensively.

"I know you don't" James said, hugging her tight. He could feel her cock still throb inside of him, making his own small cock twitch. "But there is no need to pretend that it's something its not, okay?"

"Okay." Mary said softly.

"Besides, I think you quite like the difference." James said seductively. His hand had wandered to her tits and was now rolling a nipple in between his fingers.

Mary blushed, partly because her nipples were quite sensitive, but mostly because she did in fact get off on having such a big girlcock, and the fact that it was so much bigger than James' little penis.

James chuckled. "It's okay, you can admit it."

Mary's blushing intensified. She gave James a naughty look and bit her lip. "Guilty." She said playfully, and slowly started rocking her hips back and forth again. James let out a little gasp as he felt her big, throbbing member rub inside of him again. His penis jumped between them. He quickly recovered however.

"Guilty of what?" He asked, wanting to hear her utter those dirty words again. Mary regained her confidence now, getting on her knees and picking up the pace again. James reached out and grabbed on of her boobs.

"I-" Mary hesitated, choosing her words carefully. "I like that my big cock is so much bigger than yours." Mary said, thrusting deep inside of James.

"Bigger than what?" James said, pushing Mary's buttons perfectly. Mary was now panting as she thrusted hard, deep and smoothly. This turned her on incredibly much, and she could feel herself getting close.

"I like that my huge cock is bigger than your tiny, little penis!" Mary exclaimed, thrusting hard inside of James. Her heavy balls slapped against James' asscheeks. Her large balls were boiling hot, getting ready to cum inside of him.

"Oh Mary, I love your huge cock in my tight ass!" James moaned loudly, gently squeezing Mary's nipples and breasts.

"James I-" Mary was panting and moaning like crazy. "I'm- gonna- fill- you- up!" She said, leaving pauses between every thrust.

"Cum inside me, Mary!" James said, his asshole clenching around her insane girth. He could feel his small balls tingle in his tight scrotum as he felt Mary's much larger balls slap against him. His little erection was standing straight, hovering above his belly, shaking every time Mary rammed her superior, massive, throbbing dick inside of him. He loved every second of how his little angel was fucking him with her massive dick.

"James- James I'm cumminggg!" Mary yelped. And with one final, deep thrust, she unleased massive torrents of her cum. Filling James' insides with her huge, sticky load.

"Ah fill me uuup!" James moaned loudly, pulling her close and locking her inside of him with his legs. His own little stick spurted out another small load in between the two of them. Mary hugged him back and fondled his little balls with her tiny fingers. Meanwhile her cock was still pumping huge streams of cum inside of James. Every stream lasted for about two seconds or three, and between every shot of Mary's load, there was a small pause which got longer and longer untill her orgasm came to an end.

"Hmm I can feel your tight little ass throbbing around my fat cock." She hummed softly against James' chest. Even the powerfulness of her orgasm was superior to his, which Mary found incredibly hot, and James too had discovered that this was something he loved.

"Hmm you sure filled me up baby." James said softly, caressing her little back and the contours of her hips. He could feel his girlfriends' cock slowly turn softer inside of him, allowing some of her cum to leak out. The warm water wrapped around the both of them as a warm blanket.

"I love you James. You're amazing." Mary whispered.

"I love you too baby."

What's next?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)