Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 4 by JNK357 JNK357

What's next?

The men get to enjoy the women's asses

“Well, looks like you 2 are in for it again!” Candace teasingly says to Shannon and Kelly while Michael and Brian smile anxiously. “And for being a real pain in the ass, maybe some anal is in order” Candace adds in while slapping both Shannon and Kelly on the ass. Immediately, Shannon starts to protest but isn’t getting anywhere with changing Candace’s mind. “No, no! Sorry sweetheart, but you don’t get to dictate the terms when you lose.” Shannon retorts back, still feisty “No way anyone is fucking me in the ass!” Candace looks at Michael with a smirk, then looks back to Shannon and says, “You don’t get to decide that, but for that sass, you get to go first!” Stunned, Shannon doesn’t have time to fight Michael and Candace off as they push her down onto the bed. Candace holds Shannon by the arms and says, “Don’t worry, you ass is in good hands!”

Michael spreads Shannon’s ass checks and begins to lick her lips. Trying to hold back a moan, Shannon bites her lips not wanting to admit that she is enjoying it. Candace mouths to Michael silently, “Make her scream!” causing him to shove his huge cock into Shannon’s ass, and she can’t help but scream with pleasure and slight pain. Candace grins knowing she is in complete control. Michael starts with slow, long strokes until he feels less resistance and begins to increase his pace. Kelly watches wide eyed as Nicole leans over and says, “You’re next!” with a smile. Kevin aggressively grabs onto Shannon’s ass as the tempo begins to push him closer to climax. Shannon screams out first with a surprise orgasm. Almost immediately, Michael pulls out, slaps Shannon’s ass, and turns her around to finish on her face and tits. Candace adds in an extra slap to Shannon’s ass and says, “That ass though!”

Knowing it’s her turn, Kelly sheepishly tries to negotiate with her longtime friend Nicole. Refusing to give in, Nicole leads Kelly to the bed while Shannon says, “It’s actually not as bad as I thought it would be” and shyly smiles. Nicole places Kelly’s hands on the headboard and holds them there. She then nods to Brian and says, “She’s an anal virgin so be gentle with her, but only at first” with a wink. Brian slides two fingers into Kelly and slowly moves them in and out of her lips. Kelly starts to grip the headboard tighter as she enjoys the pleasure. Feeling Kelly dripping down his fingers, Brian very slowly penetrates her ass while she closes her eyes and bites her lip at the mixture of pain and pleasure. After a few strokes pressing just the tip in and out of Kelly, she quietly starts to let out little moans. Brian pushes in a little deeper with each thrust, and once he slides all the way in, Kelly throws her head back and lets out the loudest moan of the night. Soon Kelly is white knuckling the headboard as Brian powerfully takes her ass. Nicole lets go of Kelly’s hands and reaches back for her friend’s hair and gives it a tight pull back. Not feeling timid or shy anymore, Kelly lets out a sexy scream and presses back against Brian. Feeling her enjoy it, he pushes harder and faster until he pulls out, flips Kelly over and finishes on her perky tits. “And you were trying to get out of it,” Nicole says with a smirk.

What's next?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)