The More the Merrier

Sam’s eyes opened and blinked in the gloom of the bedroom. Beth had woken first and managed to lever Sam’s body upright, her arms flopping by her side - it was a good job Sam worked out regularly and had good core strength. “It must be late, it’s getting dark outside....... Oh no! It’s Saturday! What time is it?” Sam looked round to see a bedside radio with a clock telling her it was 8:07pm.

“Shit!” said Sam’s voice, loud enough to wake the dead, but not Andy. “What’s wrong, Beth” came the concerned voice of Sam in her head.

“I was supposed to meet Rob tonight! At 8 o’clock! Oh, I’m an idiot...... we were getting along great, I really thought this might be for real this time.”

“Well let’s call him and explain. It’ll be fine” Sam said as reassuringly as possible.

“Couple of problems with that. In case you hadn’t notice our arms are completely useless. I mean he could be asleep, but we may have consider the possibility that we killed your boyfriend with that last orgasm. And even if would could wake him, I’d be talking to Rob with your voice!” Sam’s voice said as she started to sob.

“Come on Beth, we can do this! Try yelling Andy’s name, maybe my voice will shake him awake.”

“ANDY!!!” yelled Beth as loud as she could in Sam’s voice. They waited a few seconds. Nothing.

“Try it again”

“ANDY!!!” Still nothing.

“Alright, can you move us into the kitchen? My iPhone is on the counter, so if you can tap it, it will wake up, so if we can get my face in front of the screen, it will unlock and then we can voice dial Rob.”

Beth was already moving into the kitchen as her friend explained her plan. If there was a chance to rescue this situation it was worth a go.

Mercifully the phone worked and they could hear the call connect and Rob’s voice answer “Hi....”

“Hi Rob, this is Sam Smith, I’m a friend of Beths’s”

“Is she OK? Has something happened?” Rob interrupted, his voice full of concern.

Smiling inwardly at her boyfriends clear concern for her, Beth continued “No. No, she’s fine, she’s just got herself stuck in a tricky situation and she didn’t want you to worry.”

“Is she there? Can I speak to her?”

Beth hesitated - what could she say?

“Look it’s a long story and I’m sure you guys will laugh about it when she catches up with you, but she can’t get to the phone right now.....”

“This doesn’t sound great” suspicion now creeping into Robs voice. “Did she say anything else? Are we still on for tonight?”

Beth moved away from the phone and whispered to Sam “I can’t do this to him, I need to see him tonight. Is it OK if I get him to come here?”

“Of course, you idiot! He sounds sweet!” said Sam inside her head.

“Hello? Are you still there? Sam?” Rob was starting to sound very concerned.

“Sorry! I lost you for a second there. Look I can’t explain over the phone. If you can come round to my house this evening, it will all become clear.”

“Sure, give me your address and I’ll be there as soon as I can”

Beth gave her address and hung up.

“We have got to get this idiot awake so we can try and sort this out” said Sam’s voice. “Sorry Sam, I can’t think of anything else.....”

Sam’s foot kicked the corner of a kitchen cupboard and her toes splayed out with the impact.

Beth and Sam both yelped with the pain and Sam’s arms flailed in the air.

“What the fuck...!?!” said Andy in their head.

“Finally! screamed Sam’s voice. “Don’t argue, don’t say a word just pick up the knife and open us up!”

Andy knew that tone of voice and experience had taught him never to do anything other than exactly what Sam said and as quickly as humanly possible.

Sam’s arm picked up the knife, bent behind her as far as it would go and started to slide down her back, the slit opening up as it went. Her arms put down the knife and her hands pulled at the fingers as Andy started to wriggle backwards out of the suit. This was the first time of trying to get out of someone on their own and the opening was not high enough up to pull the head out of the way first. Andy struggled but managed to bend in the middle enough to pop his upper body and arms out of Sam. He picked up the knife again and made the opening larger and pulled Sam’s head forwards over Beth. Finally they both stepped out of Sam’s legs and lay her body down on the sofa to set about bringing her back.

“What happened?” asked a bemused Andy.

“We’ll tell you later” they said as both girls ran into the bedroom to get dressed. “And you might want to put some pants on, we will have company any minute!” called Sam over her shoulder.

“What the fuck is going on?” muttered Andy as he followed them into the bedroom, scratching his head.

Andy threw on some jogging pants and a t-shirt and shuffled back to the kitchen to make some coffee. He could hear Sam in the shower and knew she would be a while yet. Beth came in and Andy handed her a mug of great smelling coffee.

“You look worried” he said

“I am. Look it’s no one’s fault but my own. I had no idea that our last little escapade would knock us all out for so long. I was supposed to be on a date with Rob right now and when I woke and realised the time, I kind of panicked. Sam was brilliant and we figured out a way to call Rob and let him know. Unfortunately he wouldn’t really accept the fairly pathetic explanation from someone he’s never met, so the upshot of all that is he is on his way over and he has a really nice car, which is probably very quick. I have no idea. I have no idea what I’m going to say to him either.”

Beth looked almost as deflated as when she’d been laid over the back over the sofa the previous night.

“I hate to say it, but the truth is usually the best thing to say.” said Andy.

“I agree with the knucklehead for once” said Sam as she helped herself to some coffee. “Good call, you giant Sloth.” Sam took a slug of coffee. “On the coffee and on the advice. We are going to have to figure out better ways of managing all this if we all end up in one person again. My toes really hurt....”

“I did say sorry before I’d did it” said a very concerned Beth.

“It’s fine” smiled Sam. “Hey, I’m starving. I’m gonna order pizza. Anyone else want anything?

“Pizza is good” said Andy still concerned about Beth who had gone very quiet. “Get enough for four, I think we’re gonna be in for some deep conversations tonight.”

Sam ordered pizzas, dough balls, beer and two large tubs of ice-cream for delivery. As she put the phone down, they all heard the screech of tyres and a car door slam.

“That s what I call express delivery” said Sam trying to lighten the mood, but it was Andy’s turn to roll his eyes.

Beth was already at the door opening it as the bell rang. She flung it open to see the worried look on Rob’s face melt into joy as he saw Beth in front of him. She flung herself into his arms and starting crying.

“Hey, hey, what’s up? Are you OK?”

Sam appeared behind her friend and said “Hi Rob, I’m Sam. We sort of spoke earlier. You’d best come in. I know it doesn’t look like it, but Beth is just very happy to see you and we all have some explaining to do.”

Andy couldn’t help but feel that last remark was aimed at him. He was impressed at how much trouble he had gotten into while he was asleep.

The friends all sat in the living room and began to re-tell the story of what happened to Beth on Friday night and how things had developed from there. Beth looked sheepish as she had to explain why she hadn’t told Rob about being attacked - she simply didn’t want to freak him out.

Rob sat in silence for what seemed like an eternity to Beth while he thought.

Sam broke the silence. “Look, Rob. We decided to tell you because we felt the truth now, was better than trying to weave some story that would eventually fall apart and risk whatever relationship you two have going on right now.”

More silence.

“OK. Andy and I will leave you guys to talk. Oh, we ordered food which will be here any minute. You are welcome to stay and join us. Just so you know.”

Sam and Andy got up to leave just as the doorbell rang again. It was the mountain of food and drink Sam had ordered. Andy put the beer and ice-cream in the refrigerator and the pizzas in the oven to try and keep them warm. He turned to follow Sam into their bedroom just as Rob stood up.

Beth fearing the worst, sprang to her feet, staring into Rob’s eyes, searching for some glimmer of hope.

Rob spoke so slowly and so quietly that it felt like the world stopped, just so it could focus on what he was saying.

“Beth. I love you. I’ve loved you from the moment I saw you. I have no idea what this all means, but I can’t walk away from you. You’re gonna have to catch me up with this knife thing...... I’m not entirely sure I understand, but I trust you. If this is something you enjoyed that much, then I need to at least try it with yo ........and ........ I’m starving. Can I smell pizza?”

Beth flung her arms around him and started crying again.

Sam and Andy looked at each other and blew out the breath they had both been holding.

The four of them sat around the kitchen table devouring the food and chugging back all the beers while they just chatted and got to know each other. It turned out Rob was a cool guy, with a good job and a place by the beach. And the “nice car” Beth had mentioned turned out to be a classic 1965 red Mustang convertible. It was Sam and Andy’s dream, to cruise down the Pacific highway in a classic convertible, without a care in the world. They had hoped it might come true one day. Maybe.......

With the food and the beer gone, they made their way through to the living room to flop down into the comfy sofa and chairs.

The conversation suddenly dried up and in the silence they all knew that the only thing they hadn’t talked about was the knife that lay on the coffee table in front of them.

Rob leaned forward and picked it up. “So this is what it’s all about, huh?”

Beth looked at her friends and took the knife from his hands. “Yes. This what started it all. I guess you want to see?”

“I think I have to see....” replied Rob.

Beth gave the knife to Andy and began to undress. Rob looked a little startled at first, but soon realised that from what they’d told him about the last couple of days, seeing each other naked was nothing for these guys. Once Beth was naked Andy carefully ran the blade down her back. Rob couldn’t help but gasp as he saw his girlfriend, the love of his life, melt before him.

“What the fuck!?!? Oh shit! I mean, you told me what was going to happen, but nothing prepares you for that!”

“So brace yourself for the next bit....” said Andy who had pulled off his t-shirt and was stepping out of his jogging pants. Andy picked up Beth by the shoulders and stepped inside, one leg followed by the other. He slid his arms into Beth’s sleeves and flexed her fingers as he reached up to pull her head over his. As Beth’s hair fell back over her shoulders and her hands adjusted her face, there was the “Schluupp” sound of the seam closing. Beth’s hand reached down to pick up her dress and put it on.

Sam smiled at the thought of Andy covering Beth’s modesty in front of her boyfriend. Andy really was a softy at heart. Her gaze moved to Rob who was staring opened mouthed at the whole thing.

“Would you like a go? It might help you really understand why Beth came back for more”

Rob turned to look at Sam and nodded. “Take off your clothes, then. I think I should drive for your first time.” said Sam. Andy sat Beth down on the sofa while Sam and Rob both undressed.

“Last chance to say no...” said Sam as she moved round behind Rob.

“I have to know, so go ahead and do it.” Sam slid the knife down his back with practiced ease.

Beth’s arms caught Rob as he folded up flat and then handed him to Sam. Sam stepped quickly into the much larger legs and her arms slipped easily into Robs’. She quickly pulled his head over hers and felt her eye-line rise up as the seam closed behind her and she became Rob. “Oh my god! said Rob inside her head. “This is really real. It really is like being a passenger.”

“Yes, but you get to experience everything the driver does and feels” explained Sam. “Watch.”

Sam moved Rob closer to Beth and kissed her deeply, pulling her in for a passionate embrace. Rob felt his naked form becoming erect as his feelings mingled with Sam’s. “Holy hell. I see you mean” he said inside Sam’s head.

“Want to make a night of it?” said Beth.

“Yes.....” answered Rob’s voice “.....and Rob’s OK with it as well.”

Rob’s hand took Beth’s and all four made their way into the bedroom. Robs hands unzipped Beth’s dress and Andy stepped Beth out of it as it fell to the floor. Andy lay Beth down on the bed and reached out for his lover. Sam moved Rob onto the bed and she straddled her lover lying beneath them. Rob’s hand reached down and gently stroked Beth’s breasts. Beth’s voice moaned in delight at the tender touch and her hands gently massaged her cunt to help get her juices flowing. “Allow me.” said Rob’s voice as Sam moved Rob’s hand down to take over and began to slide two fingers in and out of Beth’s body. Andy moved Beth’s hands to cradle Rob’s penis and guide it into Beth. Sam couldn’t hold off any longer and plunged Rob’s dick into her friend. Sam moved their throbbing dick in and out of Beth’s sopping pussy in time to her breathing. Andy move Beth’s hands up to grab Rob’s shoulders and pull him down on top of them, so he could kiss his lover.

As their collective passion rose higher and higher, Andy rolled Rob’s body over and hopped up on top, kneeling Beth’s body across Rob’s as he rode up and down on his dick. Sam reached out Rob’s hands and cupped Beth’s breasts and began to fondle them as she could feel her orgasm coming closer and closer. Andy could feel the subtle stiffening of Rob’s dick that could only mean that Sam was just moments away from coming inside him. The thought of that sent an extra surge of orgasmic energy through Beth’s vagina as Andy hoped he could climax at the same time as his love.

“Aaarrgghhhh” screamed Rob’s voice, his body was wracked with ecstasy as his dick exploded with ejaculate. Milliseconds after Rob’s climax, Andy felt the tidal wave of orgasms reach their peak and he came on top of his love, Beth’s voice screaming in sync with Rob’s.

Andy let Beth’s body fall forwards on top of Rob and he smiled as he felt Rob’s arms embrace him.

They lay there, on the sweat soaked covers for 10 minutes as their breathing came back to normal.

“Wow. I get it now” said Rob inside Sam’s head.