Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 5 by poison ink poison ink

How do I respond?

Tell me more!

My cock snapped to attention with her last text, making a little tent in my boxers. Hailey had never been the type to talk dirty and had certainly never texted me about how wet her tight little pussy was. After giving myself a quick stroke, I texted her back.

Sam: Really wet? Looking at those pictures really got you horny?

Waiting for her reply, I slipped my hand into my boxers and imagined her juicy little slit. She kept it waxed smooth and I'm sure her pink pussy lips were shiny and wet now. My phone buzzed again and I checked it with my free hand.

Hailey: Sooooo wet!! followed by a few rain drop emojis. Could imagine me getting fucked by one of those big fat cocks?

I frowned a little at the second part, but continued stroking my stiff four inches. I wasn't sure that I liked her fantasizing about the basketball player's cock, but I didn't want to stop her from sending me dirty texts and decided to urge her on.

Sam: LOL I'm sure that anyone of them would love to try. You want me to come over and help you out with that horniness?

Most people that found out that Hailey and me were dating were surprised, but we'd been together for years. She'd been a late bloomer like me and we'd both had similar interests, so it was only natural that we ended up together. I wasn't until the last couple years of high school that she really began to bloom (both in height and her gorgeous curves, and now I definitely felt lucky to be dating such a sexy girl. We'd lost our virginity to each other over the summer and now I took every chance I could to get back into bed with her. My phone buzzed again.

Hailey: I wish! But my mom is home. I'll just have to make do with my fingers tonight...

A moment later, she sent a pic over Snapchat, this time of her fingers rubbing along her pussy mound through her pink panties, and by the look of it, her panties really were soaked. Fuck! What I wouldn't do to get into that sweet slippery pussy again!

Sam: You're teasing me so bad, girl! I'm gonna have blue balls later!

Hailey: Then let's play together. I'm gonna finger my wet pussy and I want you to stroke your dick and think about me handling one of those big cocks.

I groaned and texted her back with my free hand as I resumed stroking my dick.

Sam: Mmkay. I'm hard and stroking.

Hailey: Goood! Now which of those fat cocks are you imagining me with?

I had been more focused on the thought of my hot girlfriend fervently rubbing her wet slit, but played along to keep her going. I typed in the first one that sprang to mind.

Sam: The black one with the soda bottle next to it.

Hailey: Fuck Babe! You really want to stretch me out, don't you! That big black cock would split my tight little pussy in two! She added two wide eyed smiley faces after the text.

Sam: Only the best for you, girl! I added a heart emoji after mine.

Hailey: Mmmm! I wish you could feel how wet you're making me! Tell me more!

Was she really asking me to describe another guy fucking her? If it was really turning her on, how could I refuse?

Sam: He's fucking you doggystyle, hard, so your tits bounce with every thrust.

Hailey: God yes! Keep going!

Testing her more, my other hand was still stroking my cock as I imagined her with the faceless basketball player.

Sam: He keeps slamming you hard til you collapse onto the bed, still moaning for more, so he keeps fucking you against the mattress.

Hailey: Yes! Yes! So hot! I'm almost there!

I was stroking myself faster as I knew she was almost about to cum and quickly texted back.

Sam: He loses control and slams all the way into you and cums, filling up your pussy!

As I imagined the scenario I was texting to Hailey, it was too much for me, too, my cock began jerking in my hand, shooting my load over my chest, my hand, and some splattering against the screen of my phone. I hurriedly tried to wipe off the screen, leaving streaks of cum behind, but saw that she hadn't responded yet. A couple more minutes passed and I grew impatient. I texted her again.

Sam: Are you still there?

After another minute, she finally responded.

Hailey: Mmhmm... God. I came so hard, Babe. You and that big cock really got me going. I think I need a nap now. She added a sleeping emoji and then texted again, I'll talk you tomorrow. Love you.

I stared at the streaked screen of my phone, still a bit dazed myself, and reread the messages I had sent Hailey. It was all just pretend but something inside me still felt uncomfortable about telling my girl about her fucking other guys to get her off. Glancing down to my cum-glazed belly, I had to admit, it was the hottest round of sexting that we'd done...

I knew that I probably wouldn't hear from her for the reat of the night, so I cleaned myself off and settled in for a long night of video games.

What happens next?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)