Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 49 by airwreck airwreck

What do you do?

Tell Ellie to lie on top of Connie.

You decide you cannot pass up the opportunity to fuck two hot redhead sisters at the same time. You grab a couple pillows from the couch and throw them under Connie, raising her ass off the floor. You order Ellie to lie on top of her sister, between the younger sibling's outspread thighs, allowing you access to both wet, bald pussies. Ellie looks over her shoulder, grinning and winks at you, before she passionately kiss incestuously her baby sister.

You kneel behind Ellie's upturn ass and flick the tip of your cock along the girls' pussy lips. From the corner of your eyes you notice the other girls are playing with their nipples and snatches. With a smile, you push your hip forward and sink into Ellie's tight cunt. The young bartender grunts as you pound her from behind and moans in disappointment when you abruptly pull out, only to have Connie grunt when she suddenly feels her pussy filled with cock. For several minutes, you alternate between the pussies until Ellie finally begs you to fuck her like you did in the storeroom of the bar.

You grip the bartender's hips as she gets up on her hands and knees, allowing Connie to suck on her sister's small breasts. The sound of flesh slapping against flesh drown out the girls' moans. "OhGodOhGodOhGodOhGod," Ellie cries out as she starts to cum. You keep pummelling away even after she collapses on top of her sister, overwhelmed by her orgasm. Eventually you stop to allow Ellie's pulsating pussy to massage your cock. With a playful slap on her ass, Ellie dutifully rolls off her sister and you take her place between Connie's parted thighs.

Connie stares at you with lust in her green eyes as you hook her legs over your shoulder. "Fuck me," she begs and you push the tip of your cock between her pussy lips. You lean forward press your chest against her huge tits. She lets out a loud unlady-like grunt when you suddenly slam into her. You silence her cries with a fierce kiss as you accelerate the tempo of your thrust.

You had not only lucked out in poker but meeting Connie and Loretta, who not only allowed you to take their cherished virginity but now shared you with their friends and sibling! If it wasn't for their overly protective fathers you would have no reason to leave this small town consider how much pussy you are getting in just one day alone.

You break your kiss so you can watch her beautiful face twist in blissful torment as she starts to cum beneath you. The redhead closes her eyes tightly and arcs her neck before letting out an orgasmic scream. You thrust a couple more times before sinking your cock balls deep into her cunt one last time, releasing what feels like an endless stream of jizz into her womb.

"I love you," Connie whispers into your ear. You are surprised by her declaration considering that she barely knows you for even one day but you guess with the amount of amazing sex she had experienced with you she would be infatuated with you. You kiss her in response. You don't know if you emotionally love her yet but there is certainly an attraction beyond sexual.

Worn out, you push yourself off of her and lie between the two sisters, with your deflating cock resting on your thigh.

What happens next?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)