Suggest anal instead

You're stunned by your fiancee's offer, but in your head, you'd deal with the situation differently. Lily is gorgeous. It's her body that you constantly lust after, no one else's. And while her pussy may not be cooperative, she has another hole you can use. You're not sure that's the response she's looking for, but you can't help but want to give it a try.

"Babe, it's crazy that you'd offer that. It means a lot to me. But you're all I need," you reply.

"But I want you to-" Lily begins to reply.

"No, wait a moment," you interrupt. "Your body is more than enough for me. And I'm just as sorry that sex is painful for you. Penetrative sex, anyways. I want you to enjoy it, just as you want me to. And if your pussy is too sensitive, then we'll just have to practice using your butt instead," you say cheekily, chancing a smile.

Lily doesn't respond immediately, and it's clear your answer surprised her. Then she smirks back at you.

"You horny dog, you just won't let go of this whole butt thing, will you?" she asks incredulously.

"Why would I let go when your ass is so juicy?" you shoot back.

"Touché. But you know that's not going to be the easiest thing in the world either, right? I'm small, you're not. It could hurt."

"Not if we go slowly," you reply. "The last thing I want is for you to not enjoy this either. So we'll go as slowly as we have to. I promise," you say firmly.

"Practice makes perfect?" she says with a half-laugh.

"You know it. We'll practice a lot," you add, playing along.

She slaps you playfully on the wrist, but her smile deepens, and you know the moment of tension has mostly passed. You hope you can convince Lily that she doesn't need to offer you other women, she has plenty to offer you herself. You wrap your arms around her and hold her tightly.