Stick a finger in Claire's ass

Claire continues to grind against your hips as you slow your pace. You remove your left hand from her breast and stick your fingers into her mouth again to get them nice and wet.

She seems a bit confused when you remove the hand again, and a bit surprised when a wet digit is pressed against her puckered rosebud. "Oh, shit!" she exclaims with a stutter as your finger makes its entrance. "I've never had anything in my butt before."

Claire's pussy squeezes you with each gasp as you push deeper into her ass. You hold your dick still in her wet snatch while you work your finger in and out of her asshole, the teen grunting as your right hand resumes pinching her nipples.

Claire reaches down and rubs her clit as she strains to rock against your cock. "Oh, yeah! Use my ass. Use my pussy. Use all of me. Please, sir!"