More fun
Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 7 by carlsjunior carlsjunior

Next?

Stack 'em up.

Having them right where he wanted them, Rowan felt more confident to give orders now. ?Get on top of each other, like a stack.? He said, as a sheepish grin slowly crossed his face. The girls looked at each other sceptically, Angie because she was still sore and Lily because she worried that it might be demeaning. After a brief pause both girls agreed, but Lily only lowered her guard because she was **** to get off after seeing Angie's display. The girls then laid down, Angie on top and Lily below, both of their bottoms pointing towards Rowan.

Rowan had to pause briefly to admire the sight, but he quickly got down to business. He moved in and grabbed them, pulling them back so Lily was on her knees and elbows, giving him better access. Lily blushed, beginning to feel unsure of herself, but Rowan's cock rubbing against her wet lower lips took that feeling away. Then he worked himself about halfway in, eliciting a gasp from Lily. She couldn't take his whole length without screaming in pain but right now, for some reason, Rowan felt **** to make her do just that. **** to **** her all the way down and hold it in while she fruitlessly tried to escape, **** to pound her mercilessly and see her cry due to his dominance.

  • Snap out of it * Rowan told himself. The consequences of such an act would be swift and severe, he had too much to lose. Also, he had a girl who was willing and able to take him all the way right in front of him. Even if he couldn't make her cry, she would have to do for now.

?Is something wrong?? Lily asked ?Should we change position??. Rowan suddenly realized he had forgotten to keep fucking due to his distracting fantasies.

?No, I was just, er, catching my breath.? Rowan said, beginning to thrust into Lily, carefully not going past about 2/3rds of his length for her sake. He also licked two fingers and slid them into Angie's still-wet hole. It wasn't long before Angie was again cavorting and moaning, and fucking Rowan's hand back hard. Angie's performance inspired Lily, who also fucked back in earnest. Rowan reached underneath with his other hand grabbing her breast and tweaking her nipple.

It wasn't long before Lily's peak began approaching and she began bucking wildly, shaking Angie all about. The closer she got to peak the louder she screamed, gradually building up to the point where it sounded like she was being stabbed. Nevertheless, she was careful not to take him too far. Rowan pulled out when she finished cumming and abruptly moved on to Angie, giving her his full length right away. She rewarded him with a pleasing grunt/yelp.

After giving Angie a few hard thrusts Rowan switched back to Lily, who again yelled like she was dying. She'd never let anyone keep fucking her after she came before because she thought it would hurt, but she found the feeling not unbearable, but she didn't feel turned on either. She doubted she would cum again.

Nevertheless, Rowan went on switching from pussy to pussy for a little while, but remembering to go hard on Angie and hold back on Lily proved too difficult and after withdrawing from Angie, he plunged deeply into Lily's snatch. She yelped and slid off his cock.

?Ow! What the fuck Rowan?? She exclaimed. She seemed like she might be about to get up, but Angie disarmed the situation.

?My turn!? Angie exclaimed, as she pushed Lily down flat on her stomach and arched her own back, presenting her holes to Rowan. Rowan breathed a sigh of relief, but he had loved the feeling of switching from hole to hole and wanted more of it. An obvious idea presented itself when he saw Angie's two **** holes before him. He began his plan by first putting two fingers in Angie's dripping hole, ensuring they got very wet. Then he slowly poked one of them into Angie's puckered little hole. She flinched but didn't say anything or recoil. Rowan took this as license to proceed as he pleased.

Then he pushed his cock back up into her other hole. Angie gasped and excitedly pushed all the way down on his cock. Rowan obliged her with a few hard thrusts of his own but he was more occupied by by her other hole, which he had slowly **** a second finger into. Rowan was at a bit of a loss about the next part, since he had never sodomized a girl. Lily never let him anywhere near her backdoor but past girls had let him put a finger up there.

Lacking in knowledge but not hubris, he withdrew from Angie and aimed his wetness-slicked cock at her other hole. Angie froze when she felt his huge cock poking at her anal entrance. She used to love the pain and embarrassment of being sodomized, but she was unsure if her recent misadventure had caused her to develop a phobia. Plus, if he was big enough to make her pussy sore how much damage could he do to her ass? She got her first taste of that damage when he began to slowly **** his way in. Angie's anus, untouched in months, vigorously protested against the large intrusion.

This was the absolute point of no return; Angie had to decide if she was going to allow him to continue or stop him. Or at least try to stop him.

What is Angie's fate?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)