Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 51 by olly olly

Are you going to cum inside Chloë Grace Moretz's pregnant pussy?

Sophie Turner ups the ante by offering you her asshole

You're contemplating cumming right inside of Chloë Grace Moretz young pussy when you look over and see Sophie Turner using one of Emma's dildos on her ass. She's preparing herself for you.

Please log in to view the image

"I've never had it in my ass before," Sophie tells you as she bends over. She's already lubed and stretched herself. She may be an anal virgin, but she knows what she's doing.

Sophie Turner always told herself that her butt was sacred and special and she was planning on giving it up only after marriage. She didn't watch a lot of porn, but when she did it was usually anal because she had built it up so much as a special type of sex. She's currently engaged to Joe Jonas, so she had been planning on giving her ass to him - she told him this every time he begged to ass fuck her, but she's held strong. She told him it'll feel better knowing they waited.

You might not be her husband, but you're the father of the baby growing inside of her, and that's even more intimate. Giving her anal virginity up to you seems only right, Sophie thinks as she spreads her butt cheeks with one hand so you can get a better view of what she's offering.

Please log in to view the image

"Sorry, Chloë," you say as you unceremoniously pull the young blonde actress off your cock and walk over to Sophie.

Thanks to her preparations, you're able to **** your cockhead into Sophie's tight asshole without causing her too much pain.

Please log in to view the image

In fact she seems to be enjoying it, especially as she looks back and see's how upset Chloë is. Chloë gave up her anal virginity a long time ago and has since had at least a dozen men fuck her ass. She doesn't have anything as precious to offer up to you. She's kicking herself for being such an anal slut.

Please log in to view the image

Sophie's previously virgin asshole is very tight. Her sphincter hugs your cock like it's precious and delivers your entire cock great pleasure.

Please log in to view the image

For an anal virgin, Sophie is doing a great job - not asking you to go slowly, or anything. She seems to enjoy the pain - to get off on it - and it adds to her pleasure. Maybe a little bit of pain seems right since she knows she's cheating on her fiancé, and that she already basically gave up her entire body and heart to you.

Please log in to view the image

"I want to watch you while you fuck my ass, John," Sophie tells you.

You switch positions so that she's on top. She makes sure Chloë is still watching and then looks down to you as you fuck each other.

Please log in to view the image

You've got her great two pale butt cheeks in your hands, helping keep her ass spread wide and her big pregnant titties are swinging in your face.

Please log in to view the image

"Tell me what it feels like, Sophie. Tell me me what it feels like to be fucked up your ass for the first time," you tell her.

"Oh, John, you know you have the biggest fucking cock. You're like twice the size of my fiancé, I haven't even fucked him since you impregnated me because what's the point. I never thought I'd be able to handle such a huge cock in my ass, but for you I'm willing to push myself. I'm willing to destroy my ass for you." Sophie can't see your cock filling her ass, but to her it feels like a monster cock - like you'r the fucking Incredible Hulk or something.

Please log in to view the image

Sophie gets so excited talking dirty that she works herself up to an amazing orgasm. Indeed it feels like you've got the world's largest cock as you pummel her ass - and that's exactly the pleasure she needed to have her very first anal orgasm.

You like how you can watch Sophie's pussy quiver in orgasm while she rides your cock with her ass, even though it was anal stimulation that made her cum. She's got a very pretty pink pussy, and you're certain that you'll want to breed her a second time, which you tell her.

Please log in to view the image

Chloë Grace Moretz is so turned on by Sophie and your performance, especially all of Sophie's dirty talk that she gets over her disappointment that you're not fucking her and moves over to join the two of you.

You start fucking Sophie Turner from behind again, so Chloë can spread her legs in front of Sophie. Sophie then begins to finger fuck Chloë. She starts with one finger, but then easily slips in a second and a third. Before long, Sophie is actually fisting Chloë! It's true that Sophie has small hands, but still you're impressed by both of them - with Chloë that she can take it, and with Sophie that she is so willing to literally insert herself into another one of your sluts. You have a feeling that despite their initial tension that Chloë and Sophie will be spending more time together, perhaps with some strap-ons involved.

Please log in to view the image

Your balls are boiling and you feel ready to erupt - you just need to decide, which of your pregnant sluts deserves your cum more.

COMMENT TO VOTE FOR WHO GETS YOUR CUM: Chloë Grace Moretz or Sophie Turner.

Who will you give your huge load of cum to?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)