She comes clean

"I don't know what you mean, John."

"Come on! We've been friends for how long? Suddenly you're on me like white on rice. "

"Okay, okay. I'm looking for a new fuckbuddy. I decided life is to short to put up with people I don't like for sex, so i'm looking to put the buddy back in fuckbuddy."

Wait a minute.

"Did you tell Miranda you were considering me for this?" Is that why she seems so disinterested? Putting sisters before misters?

"Yeah, about that, I'm sorry about that thing with Tom earlier, that was just mean. Why didn't you tell me you still liked her? I thought you got over her when she moved away. You had dates and girlfriends, not like you were crying in your room carving her name in your arm."

Well that's a graphic image!

"You could have come to me, said," and here she lowers her voice to sound male, "Help a brother out, and I'd have been your wingwoman."

"Except for the fact that I don't talk or sound like that, Sarah, I'm not as bold as you are, as you know full well."

"Look. I like you. We're friends, you just said that, liking someone is kind of included there. I find you attractive and enjoy sex with you. Your cock makes it crystal clear that you can say the same. So the question is, are you in?

If you'd rather be with Miranda, I'm a big girl. I'll even gladly help.

I know you have eyes for Nicole and it's obvious that she wants to ride you like a pony. Honestly I don't know why you two haven't been doing it like rabbits for years now."

You have been trying to ignore that. You could be fuckbuddies with Sarah without complications you're pretty sure, but Nicole? She's basically been your best friend your entire life. What if sex destroyed your relationship? You don't want to imagine your life without her in it, it's a scary thought.

"Not that you couldn't say yes and still have Miranda and Nicole, I'm willing to share."

Choices, choices. Do you still even want to try with Miranda anymore? Should you consider acting on the obvious mutual attraction between Nicole and you? Do you want to be Sarah's new fuck buddy?

And what about Matt? It would kill him if you said yes, unless you can convince Sarah to take Matt as some kind of package deal.

You think Sarah would be up for it, but sharing with your best guy, that could be too weird.