She's grown a dick.

There, between the Red Witch's legs, you see an erect phallus pointing right at you. You know she didn't have one before--her outfit revealed that much. Nevertheless, this potion of hers seems to have given her new anatomy.

"The first sip... it worked," she says, marveling at her member. The girls around you are in an uproar, fighting for a spot at the edge of the cauldron you two occupy, and trying to scoop the mixture up to sip from their hands.

You suddenly feel the Red Witch grab your hips, pulling you up again. "As thanks for your sacrifice, I shall grant you its first use," she says. As the frenzy erupts around you, you hang helpless in her grip. The concoction seems to have your mind too numb to do anything but lay there.

The Red Witch positions her new hardware between your legs as she pulls your soaked panties off your hips. "There's still one virginity left to take..."

As you hear her speak, she prods your rear with her dick, seeking to take you anally. You moan, feeling especially horny with this smell filling your senses. You can't help but bring a free hand to your drenched cunt, frantically working your fingers inside yourself.

You throw your head back in a cry of pleasure as you feel the Red Witch enter your ass, slowly working it looser. The girls around you occasionally grope you, sticking hands into your sopping costume to fondle your breasts, or slide their fingers into your open mouth.

Your rhythmic fingering speeds up as the cock in your ass goes deeper. Soon she's inside you enough to start pumping harder, sending your body up and down, splashing the brew everywhere. You moan even louder as you feel her cock inside you with the hand you have in your pussy.

The sensations send you over the edge, and your body convulses in an orgasm, waves of pleasure overcoming your mind. One girl outside leans in to shove her tongue into your mouth, stifling your moans. You automatically kiss her back, swallowing a mouthful of the potion.

The Red Witch moans as she give your taut asshole two big thrusts, and then swiftly pulls out to aim her cock over your shuddering, soaking body. With the help of her hand, she shoots her cum all over your face, neck and chest, with some of the hot, sticky semen landing in your wide-open mouth.

More girls cheer as they come in to throw themselves over the side of the cauldron, licking you clean and scooping what cum they can off your body. You lay in a daze throughout it all, soaked in so much of god-knows-what.