Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 5 by whatever3132 whatever3132

What's next?

Sex with your brother!

Emily could feel her stomach tie into powerful knots as the wheel finally began slowly down. It then clicked to a stop. The orb grinned widely before announcing the result loudly.

“And now, you must have sex with your brother!” he shouted. If Emily wasn't already covered in white makeup, she would have been white as a sheet. Sex? With her brother? No way!

Her brother's name was Thomas. He was several years older than her and already had his own life. He was married and had two kids. In truth, they weren't really close. He had distanced himself from her when she embraced her gothic nature. There was no way she could sleep with him!

“Let's get this started!” the orb cried. His magic hands appeared and clapped twice.

Abruptly, Emily was in the center of the stage, surrounded by the audience. She wasn't alone. There was now a bed. Her brother sat on it, reading a book. Emily could feel her throat tighten. Holy hell...it was really him! Thomas glanced up from his reading and sighed.

“Oh Emily, we can't keep doing this.” he said.

“What...what is...?” she croaked.

Thomas shook his head and threw the book aside. “I know I became distant when you went goth, and this just happened when we reconnected, but it's wrong for a brother and sister to keep doing this!”

“I don't...what's happening?” Emily's brother seemed oblivious to where they were and what kind of sadistic game they were playing.

Thomas didn't respond. He merely stood up and walked over to her. He gazed down at her in a way that made Emily's skin crawl. He then lifted his hand. His fingers skimmed across her face and put a stray strand of her pink hair behind her ear. The moment his skin touched her, Emily went stiff. It was like she lost control of her body. She wanted to scream at her brother and ask him what was wrong with him, instead her voice was silent. Her arms and legs wouldn't move either! There was a popping noise next to her head.

“Oh, by the way,” the orb said. “you're still playing the previous game, so when a male touches you...”

“That's cheating!” Emily hissed, the floating ball allowing her to speak.

“Hardly! I explained the rules of the game, I let the wheel spin randomly, and now you have to do what it says! You never said the old game was over. Besides, you weren't really going to have sex with him willingly, were you? You've been saved you from the pit!” With another pop, the orb disappeared. Emily turned back to her brother, who was now staring at her with lustful eyes, creeping her out again.

“I can't resist you.” Thomas said. “Society be damned!” The crowd watching them cheered, as if this was a great moment. Her brother grabbed her face with both of his hands and leaned forward. Their lips met and Emily wanted to scream. Rather than doing that, she wrapped him in her arms and returned his affections. Their tongues explored each other's mouths, like lovers. After a few moments, Thomas pulled away and sighed again, clearly aroused. “Come on, let's do it!”

Thomas led her to the bed, where he laid on his back. Emily's body crawled on top of him and sat on his waist. She could feel something hard and hot against her. Her stomach turned at knowing what it was. His hands went up her legs and under her skirt. He gripped her butt cheeks and felt her black lace panties.

“You always told me you wanted to marry me.” Thomas said. The audience “awwed” as if this was an adorable moment.

“Yes, I did.” Emily replied. She was like five when she said that! How could he hold her to it when she was eighteen?

“Why don't you show me how much you've grown?” he teased. Emily quickly obliged. Her hands went to her blouse and she untied the string that held it together. Once it was undone, she cast it aside, revealing that her bra was also black and lacy. The crowd around them cheered and whistled, as if she was giving them a show. Thomas apparently didn't hear them and instead glared at her with hungry eyes. His fingers went up her pale sides and slipped under her bra. He began massaging and playing with her nipples. Rather than be disgusted, Emily's body broke out into goosebumps. She felt sparks of pleasure across her chest as her peaks hardened under his touch. Thomas then slipped the bra up and over her head. He cupped her breasts, as if measuring them.

“How about I use my mouth like last time?” he asked. “But leave the heels on. I love those heels.”

“Okay.” Emily replied. She could only scream from her prison as her hands went to work. She pulled her skirt and panties down, leaving her in nothing but her shoes. Her brother's hands grabbed her butt cheeks again. He pulled her forward, as her crotch went right for his face. When her pussy met his mouth, he stuck out his tongue and began exploring. Emily moaned as his skillful muscle teased her inner flesh. Her pussy rewarded her brother by leaking her juices, which he lapped up as if they were delicious. The goth girl could feel her folds tingle and heat up, enjoying every movement he made. Her hips twitched as the pleasure crept up her body. His tongue found and circled around her love button, causing her to shriek loudly. Her hands shot to her brother's head, gripping his hair.

“Love this?” her brother asked.

“Yes!” Emily cried.

“You're soaking wet! Let's get to the main event!” Thomas pushed her back to his waist. He then sat up and pulled his shirt off. The audience whistled and cheered, like he was a stripper. He still didn't seem to notice them. Instead, he grinned at his sister. “Why don't you take my pants off?” Although Emily would rather do anything else, her hands went to his crotch. She undid his pants, and lifted up her hips so she could take them off. When she sat back down, she could feel something stiff pressing against her slit. It didn't take a genius to figure out what it was.

“Go ahead, put me in.” Thomas said. “You lead this time.” Emily's lifted herself up. Her hand went to his dick. She guided it to her folds and rubbed it back and forth for a few moments, coating it in her slick fluids. Then she slowly began sitting down. She could feel her brother's large shaft spreading her apart as she went down. She then came to the horrible realization that she was having sex with her brother.

When their hips met, her brother sighed with contentment. His hands ran over her body, ultimately resting on her hips. They pressed their lips together again, moaning like lovers. Then Emily began lifting herself up and down. Each time their skin slapped together, sparks of pleasure ran over her body. They moaned against each other's mouths, apparently in bliss. Emily's pussy practically drooled with her fluids, soaking her brother's crotch. Thomas gripped her ass and held her down. He bucked her back and forth. His rock-hard dick swirled inside of her, causing Emily to shudder. She could feel her pussy tingle and the heat build up inside of her body. She couldn't believe it, but she was approaching an orgasm.

Her brother abruptly pulled his mouth away and embraced her. He trembled and gasped in her ear. She could feel his dick throb inside of her, sending a bolt of fear go through her. Was he cumming? Was this it? After only a few moments, however, it stopped. It seemed as if he managed to stop himself. He pulled away from her and put his hand on her chin.

“Why do we keep doing this?” he asked. “I can barely contain myself when we're together. I almost burst inside of you every time.” Emily felt sheer panic. He almost came inside of her! “Unless, that's what you wanted?” Oh no! Thomas licked his lips and his eyes exploded with lust. “That's what all this has been leading to, hasn't it? Our love for one another is exploding out of control. This is what you wanted, a living expression of our love. Admit it.” Emily wanted to do something, anything. She wanted to scream, run away, or even just twitch, but nothing happened. Her brother had given her an order, and her body betrayed her.

“Yes. That's what I want.”

Her words seemed to set her brother off. He grabbed her and pushed her against the bed. Now he was on top. He briefly kissed her on the lips.

“Then let's do it!” he cried. He began pounding his hips against her with all of his might. Despite the horrific situation, Emily moaned at the top of her lungs. The pleasure was overwhelming as brother ravished her. Her arms wrapped around his back and her hands gripped his shoulder blades. Her legs, still wearing the heels he loved, locked around his waist. Not only was she letting him, she was holding him close. His dick plunged into her like a crazed animal. Emily could hear the wet sound of their lovemaking every time their hips slapped together. Mixed together with her moans, all the lewd noises sounded like animals rutting. Thomas gasping in her ear. She could feel him tremble against her body. His dick, if at all possible, became even harder.

“I'm gonna cum!” he cried. The crowd watching the hot scene between brother and sister began chanting “do it!” over and over again. Emily fought with all of her might, her body quivered in delight. She could feel the waves of pleasure inside of her build up over and over again. Rather than fighting him off, her body was getting ready for it's climax.

Then her brother moaned. He slammed as deep as he could go and held himself there. His dick throbbed one more time before spurting inside of his sister. The moment Emily felt the hot magma pour inside of her, her pussy clamped and gushed with fluids. Pleasure bolted up her body and into her brain. It felt like electricity was dancing in her head. Her pupils enlarged as every muscle in her body trembled. It was like something was shocking every part of her brain with unspeakable pleasure and dissolving whatever had been there before. Her brother bucked his hips as his semen filled his sister. He erupted like never before, sending torrent after torrent of his seed. It even gushed around his shaft, dripping onto the sheets. His hips twitched, vainly trying to prolong his mind-blowing pleasure. Finally, after the greatest orgasm of his life, he slumped against his sister.

After panting for a few moments to catch his breath, he lifted his head. “How was that sis?”

Emily returned his smile. She stroked his face with her hand. “That was wonderful Thomas. God, I feel so full. How much did you cum?”

“What can I say? You turn me on.” he chuckled. “You think you got pregnant?”

“I know you did! I love you so much and I can't wait to see our child!”

The orb then turned to the crowd, but the lovers were completely oblivious. They already thought they were back in their brother's room.

“Look at that!” the floating ball cried. “A brother and sister, tied together forever!” The crowd once again “awwed.” Then they applauded. The orb materialized the two hands and clapped them together. The lovers and the bed disappeared, the game was over.

Back in Thomas' room, the brother and sister were softly kissing. Thomas had remained inside of his sister, making sure his seed was planted. When they separated, Emily giggled.

“How long are you going to stay inside of me?” she asked.

“I wish it could be forever.” he replied. Finally however, he sat up and pulled his dick free. A torrent of his semen gushed out, countless sperm already swimming to her egg.

“I don't want to apart from you anymore.” Emily said with sad eyes. “I want to be with you always.”

“So do I. Let's do it! Let's stay together!”

“Really? What do we tell your wife?”

Thomas stared at the ceiling for a few moments. He had to come to a decision...

What's next?

  • No further chapters
Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)