Sex with one of her male relatives

"Well, I know you think it's hot when two guys bang. And...I'd be lying if I said I wasn't a little curious what it would be like. What do you think, would you like knowing I fucked another guy?" you ask hopefully, looking up at Lily to see if you're making her uncomfortable.

"Ooh, that would be so hot!" she exclaims. "You should totally do it, and please let me watch," she says, batting her eyelashes at you in an exaggerated attempt to suck up to you. "What kind of guy would you wanna fuck?" she asks with a grin.

"Well, you said your family is kind of good-looking, and you're not wrong. If I were to experiment with a guy, I think it would be hot to do it with your little-brother," you pause. "Or maybe even your dad."

You never would have dreamed you would say this out loud to your fiancee, but at the same time, you never dreamed she'd offer you sex with someone else. So you mentally cross your fingers and pray she will bite.