Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 6

What do you do?

Proceed with caution

You feel like you're in dangerous, unfamiliar waters. It's wild enough that your girlfriend's sister is currently slobbering on your cock, but now this. You assume that when people want to get a little rough they sit down and have a long discussion about what are the do's and don't's, what are their preferences and limits and on and on. You assume. You've never quite gone that far. Regardless, you don't have that benefit here.

And you don't have the benefit of sitting around thinking about it. As you remain indecisive, Greenie starts to pull off her top. You reach over and grab her, stopping her. At first she looks back at you with confusion. Surely, she must think, if you're going to have some fun, she'll need to finally lose some clothes. And you agree. You just want to be the one who does it.

So you throw her hands up above her head and aggressively pull off her top, then yank down her bra. She smiles. And there are her amazing breasts, perky, fleshy, with surprisingly big erect nipples. You wouldn't have expected Tess's breasts to look that way. You're not sure if you ever had expectations for Tess's breasts.

She stands, knowing her skirt comes next. And you grab it by the waist and pull. But it doesn't budge. Clumsy moment. Not exactly what you were hoping for. You see the zipper at its side, unzip it, then yank it down.

No underwear. You're face is just about a foot from Greenie's wet, shaved, glorious pussy. It's a lot to take in. But again no time to admire it long, you're expected to be wild and rough right now.

So you grab Greenie and yank her back down to her knees, grab her head and thrust it between your legs. She makes sure her lips are parted so your cock can slide between them, until it's as deep as possible; until her lips touch your body. You hold her there.

When you hear her start to gag you relent. She slides her face off, takes a deep breath like she's coming up out of the water and then you push her back onto your cock. Within a few moments you hear her start to gag again, so you release her. You swear she doesn't slide off your cock right away. She holds herself on you for a split second and then pulls her head back.

A tear glides down the side of her face. And she looks up at you and smiles. Greenie, unlike you've ever seen her before. She wipes her chin with the back of her hand and licks her lips. "Okay... this is my fault. I wasn't clear about what I wanted."

Shit, you think. She didn't really want things this rough and you've gone and fucked it up.

She explains. "I imagine when ninety percent of girls... hell, people, say they want rough sex, they mean they want to pretend to have rough sex. But that's not what I meant. So stop going easy on me."

You take a deep breath. You still think going a little easy wasn't a terrible plan. It's what anyone in your very strange situation would have done.

"Honest answer time." Tess gives a long, seriously look. You're not sure that she's ever given you quite such a serious look before. "If I asked you to slap me as hard as you could... could you?"

You glance over at your girlfriend who is still watching intently. Then you look back at her sister.

Honest Answer

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)