Priya, the maid-of-honor and bride's bff, and quintessential "nice girl"

"Well," you say, "based on that look in your eyes, I choose...Priya. Tell me a secret about your hot best friend and college roommate."

"You really want to hear that we made out once, don't you?" Sara jokes.

"I wouldn't be opposed," you say, "but I think I deserve something juicier than that, after all my stories for you."

"Hmm," Sara says, "something juicier." Sara takes a big gulp to empty her beer. "Let me think. Actually, go get us another round and when you come back I'll have your secret."

You agree. When you come back to the table, she's blushing a bit but still has a devious look in her eyes. You hand her the beer. She immediately drinks.

"Well now," you say, "what's Priya's secret?"

"Priya's secret needs a story," Sara says. "Do you remember a bonfire we went to, when we first started dating, in that junior's backyard? One of the people there was a guy whose job was to dress up as Batman for kids, and he came in his outfit but without the mask."

You nod. "A little bit. I mostly remember how turned on I was by you, almost the whole night."

"Mmmm," Sara says. "I was really turned on by you that night too. We had only fucked a few times, and we were just getting good at it. My thoughts were constantly drifting to having you inside me again."

You smile at Sara.

"Anyway," Sara says, "we left the party kind of early, went back to my dorm room, and -- do you remember? -- it was the first time you fingered my ass while fucking my pussy. I came so hard that night...and in the shower the next morning. I loved your finger up my ass so much that told you to finger my ass again while we fucked in the dorm shower.

"But you know who else was in the dorm room that night? Priya. Priya was there the whole time, awake."

Sara continues, "Priya's secret is that she masturbated while you fucked me. She still says it was the hardest she's ever come by herself. And her first ass-play was the next morning, in the shower...while you were fucking me."

Sara takes another sip from her beer and looks at you with one arched eyebrow.