Take her to the pond

"Want to come to the pond with us tonight?" you ask her as you finish eating.

"Um, I don't have a swimsuit," she says. You can she keeps her penis a secret way more than you do. Of course she's shy.

"Most of us don't. It will be skinny dipping," you tell her.

"Oh. I can't do that," she says apologetically. "I have a little secret."

"I have a secret too. It's OK," you assure her.

"I don't know if I'm brave enough to skinny dip," she says. Now she's blushing.

"You were brave enough to stop me," you say.

Ooh... looks like you got her. Now she's biting her lip and actually paying attention to you.

"Do you want to see me naked?" she asks.

"Yes," you say, looking right at her.

"Oh my god." She covers her face with her hands.

"So are you coming?"

"I don't know! I'll think about it," she says.

You and Riley are in different cabins, so after dinner you don't see her when you go back.

Back at your cabin, Riona ambushes you, grabbing you from behind and pushing her full breasts against your back.

"Darling," she says thirstily... in the middle of the cabin, in front of everyone.

"Be patient," you tell her, and she lets go. You like Riona... you really do. But tonight she's not the one you're after.

Everyone's shaving their legs and getting ready like this skinny dipping party is a big dance. You do some grooming yourself, and before long it's dark and late, so it's time to get sneaking. The coaches definitely would not like this.

You and the girls sneak through the woods to the pond, where most of them are brave enough to completely disrobe and splash into the water. You strip down as well, and your penis gets a lot of surprised and admiring looks.

Riley does show up, looking nervous. She comes over to you, politely not staring. Without a word, but with a lot of tension on her face, she takes off her clothes and stands beside you. That must have taken a lot of courage, not that she has anything to be ashamed of. Her nipples are small, but a pretty pink and already hard. Those 34B breasts would fit nicely in your hands, but it's her athletic legs and the curve of her lower back into that perky ass that you can't look away from.

That, and her cock which is not as big as yours, but will be a solid six inches when it's hard... which will be any second with all these naked girls around. She's totally shaved down there...

"So," she says, looking expectantly at you.

"You are beautiful," you tell her.