Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 11 by SimpleWriter SimpleWriter

Whose turn is it this time?

Holly again, then Rose again

Holly looked down at Emma. "Emma? You haven't had a go yet, have you?"

Emma licked David's cockhead, making the huge mushroom twitch a little. She looked over his stiffening member nervously. She desperately wanted to feel this thing inside her, but what if he pushed too hard? She was tiny, where would all that mass even go?

"Um, one of you can go again. I don't mind."

"Oh, come on!" said Rose. "Every time we have a..." She was obviously about to say "meeting", but the AGBCC was a secret club. "...a girls night, you always talk about how desperately you want a really huge cock! You're not chickening out, are you?"

Holly put her hand over her mouth and giggled. "Remember that time when we were all seniors and we got fake IDs?"

"Fake IDs?" said David. "So you girls had a little adventure, huh?"

"Oh yeeeaaahhh!" said Rose. "God, Emma spent a whole week begging us to go to this one bar halfway across the state because they had a mechanical bull. She kept saying she wanted to set it to max and ride it until her thighs were raw!"

"Right!" agreed Holly. "But then... you know. It didn't work out."

Emma's cheeks flushed. The girls were kind enough not to say this in front of David, but Emma had backed out after they arrived because the bull looked too scary. She was the only one who hadn't even tried it.

"Hey, come here," said David. Emma reluctantly crawled forward, too embarrassed to look at him. He wrapped his big arms around her and said, "I'd absolutely love to fuck you. You're cute as hell! But if you're not feeling ready for it, we can do it another night."

Emma looked up at his big, blue eyes. "Really?"

Holly rubbed Emma's shoulders from behind her. "Absolutely! We can all get together another time. Although, you probably shouldn't wait too long. Rose and I might lock him down as a boyfriend!"

A twinge went through Emma's thighs. The thought of these three being more than a kinky hookup, making a permanent thruple, made her wet. That would just be so perfect. She couldn't say anything as Holly slipped down to the foot of the bed and got between David's legs. She watched as the taller, bustier, sexier girl took the big man in her mouth and swallowed much more of his cock than Emma had been able to. It was like watching a magic trick, and it got Emma as horny as she'd been all night.

David let go of Emma and sat up. He put his large hands on Holly's waist and gently turned her around, guiding her to get on all fours facing the foot of the bed. He knelt behind her, and Rose knelt to his left. She picked up his big cock and guided it towards her sister's waiting pussy. David put his hands on Holly's hips and pushed his way into her.

Emma couldn't believe how erotic this looked. In her current position, Holly's big breasts hung down below her and swayed with David's motion. Rose still had her hand on the base of David's cock, and the two of them were making out passionately as he worked his way in and out of Holly. Emma had been fantasizing about this guy for the last two years, and now she was getting a personal show of him fucking her hottest friends. Of course her fingers were in her pussy!

Rose broke the kiss and winked at her. "Hey Emma! Go get my phone!"

"Okay!" said Emma as she hopped off the bed.

As she ran out of the bedroom, she heard David say, "That seemed a little rude."

"Nah, don't worry about it. She likes being helpful. She used to fetch stuff for us all the time back in high school. I don't think Holly and I had to carry our books even once for the last semester."

Emma found Rose's phone (a rose gold iPhone, naturally) in the living room. She glanced at her backpack under the table and remembered the rulebook, but a loud squeak from Holly sent her running back to the bedroom.

Emma came back in to find Rose was now standing next to David. She was standing kinda on one leg, except that her other leg was hooked over his shoulder. He was licking her pussy as he fucked Holly from behind. Holly had dropped from her hands to her elbows and was moaning about how she couldn't take more but he shouldn't stop.

"Great!" said Rose when she saw Emma. "You can take some pictures! You know, for posterity!"

Emma understood that this was for the club. All the girls would want to see this. She started taking pictures. David turned to smile at her, then pulled out his huge cock and laid it in the crack of Holly's ass.

"Nooo!" cried Holly. "Please put it back in!"

"Just a sec," said David, teasing the poor girl by slowly rubbing his monster up and down her voluptuous ass crack. "Let her get a few good pics."

Emma took a ton of pics. She couldn't concentrate on whether they were good or not, she just wanted to take as many pictures as possible from as many angles as possible. She did the best job she could one handed, since her other hand was obviously required between her legs.

She walked around the bed to get pictures of David's huge cock, of David licking Rose's twat, of David sucking on Rose's big tit as he reinserted himself into Holly, of David ramming into Holly so hard that she completely collapsed forward onto the bed. She filled up the memory of the phone as David sent Holly into a screaming orgasm.

David didn't even slow down. He pulled right out of Holly as soon as she was done and grabbed Rose to throw her down on the bed. He mounted her missionary style, too worked up for any kind of style or experimentation. Rose wrapper her slender arms around his neck, loving how deep he could get in this position.

The phone full, Emma collapsed to her knees on the floor next to the bed. She frigged her little pussy with both hands as she watched the fuckfest.

After a minute, Holly sat up weakly and got off the bed. She bent down next to Emma and said, "Hey, are you feeling overwhelmed by all this?"

Emma could just nod and whine a little as she frantically pushed herself towards her second orgasm of the night.

Holly smiled reassuringly. "If you want, I could go get something that might make you feel a little more secure?"

What does she want to go get?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)