Go out on the balcony with Carli

You met Carli out on your balcony, being sure to shut the glass door behind you so no one could hear you. You stood side by side, leaning over the edge, looking out at the city. The tension between you both was thick and neither of you conceded to talk first. Finally, Carli broke.

"So, what? You just thought you'd double your money and knock us both up? Was it the same night?" Carli's tone was pointed, staccato. She was angry with you, although a bit hypocritical given that she was cheating on her boyfriend and was going to make him raise his best friend's kid.

"Carli. No, I didn't intend it. Jesse came home right after you left and fucked me while I was asleep," you stuck with the lie, "You ask me, I think it's amazing I knocked both you up in consecutive loads. Usually you gotta save that shit up." You playfully grasped at your crotch.

Carli playfully punched you in the shoulder.

"I know I shouldn't be angry. But seeing you rub Jesse's belly, knowing your seed is in her too, it kind of made me jealous. Like I'm sharing the father."

"You kind of are. I'm not Ken. I'm not your to-be husband."

Carli turned to you and placed a loving hand on your cheek. Her soft fingers stroked and circled your lips.

"Yes, but you're my daddy. You'll always be the father of my kid. Or kids, god willing. I'd love a huge family. And I'd love for all of them to be yours."

"Why me?"

Carli leaned into you for a hug. A more-than-friends hug. You looked through the glass down the hall to be sure no one could see. Ken was still on the couch, now swigging down a mixed drink to help numb him to his reality.

"Ken has a good job. He's built, takes care of his body. He's a kind man. He'll make a good father, he'll raise our children right," Carli looked up into your eyes, her long curls and crystalline eyes putting you in a trance, "But if I'm being honest, he's so plain and boring. I told you how cautious he was, how he wouldn't even fuck me when I was fertile, no matter how horny I was or how much I begged. He doesn't seem to have any interests or kinks beyond missionary or doggy. And that's just sexually. He works his 9-to-5, goes to the gym, and plays video games or watches movies. There's just no excitement." Carli got on her tip toes and planted a wet kiss on your lips. She sucked them in, and shove her tongue into your mouth. You kissed her back in turn and let your tongue tumble with hers.

She leaned back with a smack, "See? Ken would never kiss me like that." She released your hug and rubbed her pregnant belly. "Ken would never give me a baby the way you have." She reached out a hand and grasped your cock through your jeans, "And he could have never fucked me the way you have. I've never been fucked by such a huge cock, John. No matter how many times Ken fucks me, there's a spot deep in my pussy that's only been marked by you. A special place that will always be yours. My daddy's. You and your cock have given me everything I wanted." Carli sulks away from you, crossing her arms and walking to the other end of the balcony. "So that's why I'm jealous when I see someone else with you. I've made you a daddy, and you've made me a mommy. But someone else has already done that for you too. I just thought we could be special to each other."

"You are special. We're each other's secret." You look back behind the glass -- no one's paying attention. You go behind Carli and place your arms over hers, grinding your crotch into her ass. "Jesse doesn't know about us either. So it's our job now to protect our families from our secret. Together." You lick the backside of Carli's ear. She purrs into you. You snake a hand down her yoga pants and feel her wetness seeping out of her panties. You take you other hand and grab her by the throat. She nearly yelps but stops herself to avoid suspicion. Your cock is rock hard against her ass, prodding out of your shorts and into her clothed asshole. "Between the four of us, all our children will be mine. You understand?" Carli mews and nods beneath you. "And anytime I want you, I can have you. Just like I have a bigger cock and fuck better than Ken, you've got a tighter pussy, a tastier mouth, and you'll certainly breed better kids than Jesse."

"Take me," Carli's eyes roll into the back of her head, your breath hot on her neck, "I need you to take me now."