Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 18 by fikka fikka

Did you underestimate Tom once more ?

Obviously

Tom had been enjoying himself too much grinding his cock between Miranda's ass-crack but he was well aware of her impending orgasm and had been priming himself for his next plan of action. He chucked at his villainous thought, I never thought I'd be enjoying toying with John's crush so much. Her pussy, her ass.,.. they're so divine. I just can't wait to have my way with her. But she's not the cherry, she's only the cake, a cake I'm gonna love devouring none the less. My cherry is... Nicole.

Tom had to take a longer pause with his grinding as imagining having his way with your innocent virgin friend was exciting him more than he had been feeling so far. I can't wait to see John's face as Miranda and Nicole will writhe in pleasure by my monster cock, he continued with his imagination and resumed his grinding on Miranda's ass. With his towering height over Miranda he peeped down over her shoulder to see Nicole perform her dare. She had her eyes closed and was herself breathing heavily matching Miranda's. Both the unsuspecting girls had their eyes closed and they enjoyed each others touch and feel.

It would be just a few more minutes for Miranda to open her flood gates. Nicole continued to lap at her clit with her open mouth with Miranda having a tight hold behind her head and securing her face in place. Tom grabbed the base of his dick and pointed it downwards, readying it for his next move. But as he did that due to the tight confines of the space the tip of his dick brushes against Miranda's spread asshole. The contact was barely for a milli-second and it didn't register in Miranda's head but her body reacted by clenching her butt. Satisfied, Miranda had no clue of his actions, Tom peeped again closely observing Nicole's movements and mentally began a reverse countdown for his ambush.

3... 2... 1... and go ! Tom said to himself as he let go of his dick and jammed forward. The angle was still not proper to penetrate Miranda but that was not his plan. His long shaft slid along Miranda's pussy lips like before and would have stood out at least six inches but found another entry this time - Nicole's unsuspecting mouth. Miranda sensed there was some commotion going on but chose not to get interrupted, she was in her happy place with her eyes close, where the rules were dictated by the wants of her pussy. Feeling Nicole's tongue suddenly disappear from making contact with her vagina she pulled her face further into her sex using both her hands now.

Nicole was absolutely not prepared for this sudden attack. Tom's monster of a dick had been slick and slid on top of her tongue and lodged itself six inches deep in her throat. She frantically tried to pull back but had been restrained in place unknowingly by Miranda. Nicole was having difficulty accommodating the girth of Tom's dick in her mouth while on the other hand Tom was enjoying his best deep-throating experience, that too an unsuspecting girl.

Happy to see Nicole not able to pull herself back and off his dick Tom decided to make the most of this situation. He started to face-fuck Nicole pulling himself back a few inches and then jamming back as deep as he could reach between Miranda's thighs. Oh fuck, it worked better than I expected, damn right the best throat fucks are when they don't know what hit 'em, was all he could think of as he enjoyed now using your childhood friend's mouth for his sexual gratification. His dick oozed a little precum as he fought hard not to explode and mixing with Miranda's nectar in Nicole's mouth.

Nicole was totally repulsed. Never in a million years she would have wanted anything to do with Tom's dick and now it was sawing in and out of her mouth lodging itself deep in her throat. She could distinctively make out his salty taste compared to Miranda's sweetness in her mouth. She felt disgusted, partly at Tom but partly at herself, knowing fully well that she got bamboozled into this situation because she was over confident. The thing was she considered herself the Queen of everything, just like on a chess board where the Queen can do almost everything. But the fact was Nicole was a sweet, innocent and caring person and her over confidence mostly landed her in all sorts of sticky situations.

This was definitely one of those sticky situations as her mouth was fast approaching all the fluids it could hold. While she was slurping Miranda's pussy juice, she had no qualms of swallowing down her saliva as it swelled in her mouth. However, now, just the thought of swallowing Tom's seed down her throat made her nauseate. Unknown to Miranda her pussy was now getting the sensations from two individuals. Tom's dick as is sawed along her pussy rubbing against her inner folds spreading them open, while Nicole's lips that wrapped around Tom's dick rubbed against her outer folds. Nicole's **** need of air as she choked in between caused wonderful tingling sensations she had never experienced before.

Nicole prayed for her knight in shining armor to come and rescue her - at least that's the fantasy she played out in her mind every night. Confined and bound by a vile man taking liberties with her, a knight rescues the princess. That's the fantasy all girls have, was the rationale she gave to herself every time when her depraved thoughts subsided after her climax every night. Some nights her knight was stuck in traffic in her imagination and the vile man took more liberties than usual but none the less her knight eventually always did show up.

From your vantage point you had no clue as to what was transpiring, let alone Nicole's prayers reaching you. All three of you could see that Nicole seems to have doubled down her efforts but that was probably because Miranda looked like nearing her orgasm. Sarah was the first person to get wind of what was going on and she made it evident as she started to climax uncontrollably, the power-play by Tom, taking liberties with a nubile, helpless girl sent her in a whirling tailspin of emotions - pleasure, ecstasy and depravity. She had already been on the verge of cumming as she relished on the feeling of watching her student's performance, but this was something else. This was her essence... her ethos.

As Matt helped aid Sarah through her climax you stand shell-shocked looking at the closet. If you didn't know better, not only did Miranda have a hand in deciding Nicole's dare and putting her in this fateful position but she literally now had both her hands holding the poor girl in place while Tom took unrestrained liberties violating her mouth. You could now see Tom jack-hammer his hips wildly holding onto Miranda's waist tightly. Tom was not taking any pauses and the continuous friction Miranda was receiving was sending her to new heights.

Poor Miranda, she must be close to orgasming to notice what's she doing to Nicole, you defend her in your mental tribunal. You don't realize but all this depravity has made you extremely horny as you grab your dick all of a sudden and that's when you start to feel jealous of Tom. Is it what's he is doing to your crush Miranda or what he's doing to your childhood friend Nicole making you horny, you cannot pick. On one hand it's your crush who has always been oblivious to your existence but for whom you always have had the hots. And on the other hand it's your childhood friend who always had love and care for you but you never had the hots for. Even though it seems like a simple choice, you are so conflicted.

Postponing pondering this thought you decide on attending to immediate matters in hand. Quickly scanning the room you bring your veiny, angry cock out in the open, the confines of your trouser making it intolerable for you. As you massage yourself to full erectness in no time, you realize you've been caught. The douchebag is giving you a thumbs-up sign as he seduces one girl of yours and violates the other girl in your life.

Oh my God, look at the dork jacking himself off to me pleasuring his girls, unbelievable, was all the thought it took for Tom to lose his resolve of mental focus to withhold cumming. He had mastered his technique of prolonging his sexual high but this was something even he was not prepared for - to see a guy beat off while his loved one(s) got conquered. Corrupting a guy's wife he dearly loves, a fiancée he dearly wants to wed, a girl-friend he dearly fucks, a crush he dearly lusts, a sister he dearly protects, a mother he dearly respects, a cute relative he dearly adores, a childhood friend he dearly likes, was his craving. This was his essence... his ethos.

Nicole tried her best to pull her head back as she felt the increase in throbbing of the dick pumping in her mouth. She looked up pleadingly at Tom but it was Miranda's hands that were restricting her head. One second she pulled back, the next she would get pulled in again by Miranda when finally Tom erupted. Nicole was too tired to put up any kind of fight anymore and only her soft whimpers could be heard "Gawk..., gawk..., gawk..." as she breathed heavily.

The copious amount of cum Tom poured into Nicole's mouth **** its way down her throat. Miranda had finally lost the feel of Nicole's lips on her pussy and was only left with length of Tom's dick still pressing onto her vagina. Miranda was now very near to orgasming, merely seconds away. She finally opened her eyes looking down at Nicole, feeling robbed of a feeling she not only longed for but downright deserved to have. That's when she saw Tom pump his last few strokes into Nicole's mouth, cum dripping between her lips.

It came as a shock to Miranda as well and she let go of Nicole's head but Tom was still not done pumping his full load and quickly caught hold of Nicole's head for his final thrusts.

Please log in to view the image

Finally when he was done shooting his last glob down Nicole's throat he let go and watched her fall back on the floor on her butt. For Miranda it was criminally obscene to watch Nicole get violated in such close proximity to her but it was also deeply arousing to her, sending her imminent orgasm to astronomical heights. She squished her thighs hard locking Tom's contracting dick in place when her dam burst. "OH, GOD! I'm Cumming" Miranda screamed as her orgasm rocked her body. Tom wrapped his arms around your crush's body as he tried to keep her steady from thrashing around and helped her ride the wave down.

Oh God, Tom's dick made Miranda come so hard, was all you could think of as you furiously pumped your shaft up and down without a care in the world. The gravity of that thought still not sinking in your head completely. You continue analyzing that statement as you jerk yourself, repeating it over and over again in your head and only after the tenth time it circulated in your head it became lucid, Tom's dick made Miranda cum, not Nicole's tongue.

And that's when you erupted which luckily goes unnoticed without any fanfare and you quickly tug yourself back in feeling embarrassed. Nicole is still recovering from her **** while Miranda slouches like a puppet in Tom's embrace swinging gently back and forth, the son of a bitch was not done toying with her body as he roamed his one hand all over her heaving tits and with the other her dripping wet pussy.

Nicole stood up and walked back next to you to pick a name from the bowl. You can see the swell of tears in her eyes but it is not because of what Tom did to her, it's what her knight in shinning armor didn't do. As she is about to draw a name she gets interrupted by Sarah. "Damn Sarah, do you always have to be such a stickler for rules", you scowl.

Does Nicole have to re-do her dare or is there a twist ?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)