Lisa and Sarah return home.

Beth and Felicia had been home by themselves for about three hours before a key turned in the lock and Lisa and Sarah let themselves in. The four sisters stood in an uncomfortable silence for a long moment before Lisa eventually broke the silence, stating that she needed a shower.

Felicia chuckled, “Yeah, I bet you do.” Lisa grinned back, Sarah blushed, and, the tension broken, the girls all shared a good laugh before Lisa exited to the bathroom. Sarah sat down on the living room floor in front of the couch where Beth and Felicia were seated, and answered the barrage of questions the unmarked sisters had for her. No, she couldn’t explain what it was that made her bend over. Yes, the sex was really, really good. No, she wasn’t drunk. Yes, the bro had a really big dick. No, she hadn’t planned for anything to happen. Yes, doing it in front of other people was kind of hot. Yes, he really had fucked her four times in total, and no, she didn’t know his name.

“It was honestly kind of surreal, like, until I got back here, I felt like I was a different person. I’m really embarrassed you guys saw me like that, but I can honestly say I don’t regret it. Definitely a once-in-a-lifetime experience.” Sarah looked up as the sound of running water stopped, “I do need a shower, though. Hopefully Lisa didn’t use all the hot water.” She picked herself off the floor and left the room, leaving Beth and Felicia alone again. They gave each other a shrug and shook their heads.

“I think I’ll leave ‘Getting Fucked By A Frat Douche In Public’ as a never-in-a-lifetime experience, personally,” Felicia remarked, and Beth gave a light chuckle and nodded in response, but didn’t vocalize a reply. In truth, she was surprised at how satisfied and peaceful Sarah seemed about the whole situation. She kind of expected her two lost sisters to be upset, or angry, or remorseful, or… anything but normal, really. Beth actually couldn’t remember the last time Sarah seemed so happy and carefree.

Lisa entered the living room next and plopped down in between her two sisters. “Much better,” she sighed, “I’m still pretty sore, but it’s definitely the good kind of sore.” Felicia rolled her eyes and turned her attention to her phone, so Lisa focused on Beth instead.

“Sarah had a lot to say,” Beth admitted, “I’m guessing you found DKM dick to be equally enlightening?” Beth tried to make it sound like she was teasing Lisa, and not asking to hear more about the depravity her sisters had sunken to this afternoon. Lisa, of course, was only too happy to provide more details.

“Oh my god, Beth, it was honestly the best sex I’ve ever had. And it’s not just because what’s-his-name had a big dick, either, I mean, that helped, but I think there’s some sort of psychological mumbo-jumbo that comes into play when someone marks and fucks you in front of other people. Like, something about the id and the ego or whatever, you know? And I mean, that whole 'Stallion' thing was stupid and corny, but, when I just let go and went along with it… Oh God, fucking unbelievable. You know?”

Beth shook her head. “I don’t think I do know, but I’m glad you had a good time.” But when Lisa met Beth’s eyes, she saw that her words were definitely having an effect on her younger sister. She was about to start talking again, when Felicia’s phone went off in her hands with the unmistakable sound of an incoming message.