Sarah

You were hopping you could get Miranda back in the closet with you, but you unfortunately draw Sarah.

Before stepping into the closet, you dare Sarah to stick a finger in her ass. You happen to know that despite her reputation, she is an anal virgin, if her drunk confession at a different party is to be trusted.

"OK, if its just the one" says Sarah

You go into the closet, Tom shuts the door and he walks back to the group with Miranda.

You can't see anything but judging from the other's reactions, Sarah swiftly completed your dare.

"that was an easy dare John, I bet you wish you could have seen me do it though" Sarah says.

"hand me the bowl" you hear

"ooooh look who I got!" Sarah says