Keep probing [Route B2]

With her clit and anus both being massaged her pained expression has dissipated and she even lets out a soft coo of pleasure.

Since she is starting to enjoy it why not give her a birthday treat you think.

You're sure she must be a virgin, so you shouldn't insert a finger into her pussy... but her anus... fair game right?

"Mmmm," she moans again as your increase the pressure on your thumb circling her clit.

You edge your index finger slightly deeper into her anus.

She shifts slightly, and her face twitches, but you persevere.

Pushing upwards with a bit more **** your finger slips deeper into her warm rough anal cavity, up past the first knuckle.

"Ugh!"

Her passage starts to instantly tighten, but before it tightens too much you push on to the second knuckle, forcing your finger deep into her tightest of all tight holes and start to wiggle it around and massage her anal cavity.

"Arggggggh!" She screams! And you feel your arm being yanked away as she pushes back her chair and stands up ripping your finger free from her arse. She hurriedly backs away holding up her dress so she can see if you did any damage, at the same time she is also showing everyone her bare pussy.

"Argh! He stuck his finger up my bum!" She scowls. Her face a mix of rage and pain.

"What? No!" You begin to protest.

Already her father has sprung up from his chair, as everyone else gasps.

You hold out your hands in protest not noticing you are showing them all Exhibit A - your finger dripping with crushed pea and pussy juice.