Nicole

"Nicole!" Tom announces with a grin. "I always heard you were a bit of a gymnast, so I'm going to test your balance!" Tom walks back to the closet, opens it, and takes out a broom. "Now, I'm going to have Matt and John hold each end of the broom, while you stand over it. They'll then start lifting, and you'll have to maintain your balance while straddling it, until your feet are completely off the ground. You can't use your hands to hold onto them or the broom. If you can keep your balance for 10 seconds, I promise not to touch you for the rest of the game. But if you fall, you'll have to take off all your clothes and go the rest of the game naked!"

Nicole looks horrified at the dare. Personally, you think it'll be an easy challenge for her, as she's been a gymnast since she was 8, and can't figure out why she'd be so nervous. Still, a dare is a dare, and you and Matt step over to the broom, each picking up an end and holding it so it's about two feet off the ground. Nicole walks over slowly, and, biting her lower lip, lifts one leg over the broom so she's standing over it, facing you. You can't help but glance at her ample breasts and shapely hips, barely constrained by her lacy underwear. You look up just in time to see her looking at you, and flush with guilt, but surprisingly it doesn't look like she minded your gaze. Instead, she gives you a shy smile, obviously trying to keep her nerves down.

"Remember, the 10 seconds don't start until you're fully off the ground. Matt, John, start lifting whenever you're ready!" Tom announces.

With a slight nod to coordinate your movements, you and Matt slowly start lifting the broom. Soon, the metal pole is nestled between Nicole's thighs and pressing gently against her panties, causing her to gasp slightly. As the pole keeps lifting, you can't help but notice that it's causing her panties to ride up, and giving you a very clear look at the outline of her pussy lips through them. Nicole lifts up onto her tiptoes, and spreads her arms to keep her balance.

As you and Matt finally lift the broom high enough that you're now both completely taking Nicole's weight, you're amazed at just how light she feels. Nicole lets out a little squeak as her feet leave the ground, and almost instinctively reaches down to grab onto the broom handle with her hands. She stops herself at the last second, and, concentrating hard on keeping her balance, spreads her arms back out.

"1... 2... 3... 4..." Tom starts the count. You notice that Nicole seems to be trembling with the effort, and is biting her lower lip so hard it's gone white. She also seems to be leaning forwards towards you as much as she can without falling, taking as much of the weight on the front of her pelvis/crotch as possible. You're not sure why, but can't complain as it gives you a fantastic view down her bra of her breasts, which are jiggling in time with her trembling. Looking down, you're also surprised and yet turned on when you notice that the front of her panties is darker where it pressed against the metal pole, and realize that her pussy must be dripping wet. You figure having a metal pole pressed that firmly between her pussy lips must have been too stimulating.

"5....6....7....8...." Nicole seems near the end of the challenge, and looks to have it in the bag, but your distraction by her breasts causes your concentration to slip slightly, causing you to lift your end of the broom slightly higher than Matt. This causes her to shift backwards a bit, taking more of her weight between her ass-cheeks than her thighs. It isn't much of a shift, and you expect her to regain her balance quickly, but instead she yelps loudly and jumps, causing her to lose her balance and fall off the pole, landing in a heap on the ground.

"Ooooh, sooo close, but so far!" Tom gloats. "Welp, hop to it, get those bra and panties off! I'm sure everyone's dying to see what's underneath!"

Reluctantly, Nicole gets, up, and, reaching behind her, unhooks her bra, letting it slide down her arms and revealing her firm, perky tits. You can tell that they're slightly flushed, the nipples poking out from sexual excitement. Then, much more slowly, she reluctantly reaches down to her panties. Facing away from you, she bends over and slowly starts sliding them off. You watch in fascination as slowly inch after inch of her perfect heart shaped ass is revealed, until the panties fall down to her ankles. As she starts lifting one leg to step out of them, you notice a glint of something shiny, something between her ass cheeks... It can't be....

"Oh my god Nicole, is that a jeweled butt plug?!?!?!" you involuntarily blurt out.

Nicole, who was in the process of stepping out of her panties, immediately straightens and whirls to face you, embarrassment plainly written all over her face and trying to hide it from everyone else. However, with her panties still around her ankles and moving too fast, she trips and stumbles instead, landing on her hands and knees, conveniently giving you and everyone else full view of her ass sticking out. There's no doubt: A pretty little purple gem in a stainless steel setting was nestled against her asshole, unmistakably the base of a butt plug.

"Oh dear, guess the secret's out now!" Tom snickered. Looking between him and Nicole, who had quickly scrambled back to her feet and was now trying unsuccessfully to cover both her tits and her ass, you finally put two and two together: Tom must have stuck that butt plug in Nicole's ass while they were in the closet before, and that's why she'd been sitting and acting so weird.

"Wait a minute, neither of you had a dare while you were in the closet!" You fairly shouted. "Nicole, why did-"

Nicole quickly cut you off with a shushing noise. "Look, that's between me and him. He knows something that I would rather stay private, and leave it at that!"

Without giving you or anyone else a chance to respond, she walked over to the bowl while still completely naked (save for the butt plug), and pulled out a name.