She was the high school slut

"Well," Jamal says, "We went to high school together." he still seems surprised by the revelation and is being pretty vague.

"Oh" Erin shrugs. That doesn't seem like a reason to suggest he knows her well, she seems to be thinking. As are you as you watch from the sidelines. But Erin is never satisfied with a vague answer when there may be perverted details to turn her on "Were you a thing?" Jamal hesitates to answer. "Did you fuck?"

"Well..." Jamal doesn't know whether to smirk or blush. "Sure... I mean.... a few times."

"A few times." Erin smiles. "Sounds like you knew her very well."

"No. It wasn't like that." Jamal tries to explain gingerly. "I mean, everyone did. She kinda fucked all the boys in our class. And some of the other classes too. She was kinda the class slut."

And Erin's face is painting with a curious emotion. She's clearly turned on to hear this, and yet she seems concerned. And you know exactly why. If this intern Nathalie is such a renowned slut, why did she have such trouble seducing her at work?

Jamal goes on. "Then she got expelled when she got caught fucking the basketball team after practice."

Erin shakes her head. "She seems like such a quiet, sweet, normal girl at work."

Jamal shrugs. "So do you."

"Do you think she's still a bit slut?" Erin says

"I dunno" Jamal answers. "You're the one that made out with her. I haven't touched her since we started working together. If you think... wait... I'm remembering it wrong."

Erin looks quizzically.

"She didn't get suspended for fucking the basketball team. Coach caught her and she fucked coach to keep him quiet, then she got caught... wait... the principal found out that she was fucking the coach so she started fucking him, then his wife told the school board. I think that's how it went."

"Sounds like she's quite a girl. Sounds like she'll fuck anyone." Erin says, you can tell feeling spurned by this girl's rejections.

"Well, I guess so." Jamal answers. "I'm kinda surprised she made out with you though. Cause from what I remember she didn't care about girls at all. She was just into dick.... like couldn't get enough. But there were some guys who, like, tried to get her to have threesomes with their girlfriends and she never would."

Erin nods. Of course she told you that this girl, her target, was neither gay nor bi, but she thought she could still work her magic. Maybe she really can't. Now you see the gears in her mind working, hatching a plan. Maybe instead of convincing Nathalie that she should want her pussy, she should come to Nathalie with what she really wants.

Later that night, as you jerk off onto your pretty girlfriend's face, telling her what a great job she did with Jamal, she definitely seems contemplative.

"I'm sorry hon" She says, still happily slicking your jizz from her cheeks and licking her finger clean. "I'm just thinking about how to beat you at this stupid contest... and I think I have an idea."