Susie

“I think it’s the birthday girl’s turn,” Amy announced, turning to my sister. “Truth or dare?” she asked her.

“Guess I’m going to stick with truth,” she answered.

Amy grinned, like she knew just the right question to ask her. “Ok, girlfriend. Have you ever fantasized about having sex with your brother?”

Susie blushed deeply. “Really? Is that the best you could come up with?” she tossed back at Amy. “I don’t think I have to answer that. Maybe I’ll chose dare instead.”

“Oh, no,” Beth chimed in. “You can’t change your choice after the fact. If you don’t answer the question then you have to do a forfeit.”

“What’s the forfeit?” she asked.

“Hmm, we hadn’t thought about that,” Beth said, scratching her chin. “What do you think, Amy? What should the forfeit be?”

“How about she has to take off her shorts and stay in just her panties for the rest of the game?” Amy suggested. “Or aren’t you wearing any panties under those shorts, Susie?”

I perked up a little, paying attention to this new twist. This could get interesting, I thought.

Susie blushed a deep red again. “I don’t think I have to answer that,” she said. “But ok, I guess I’ll go with the truth,” she decided. She blushed even deeper as she looked straight at me and said, “Yes, I’ve fantasized about having sex with David. There, are you all happy now?” Her eyes shot darts at Amy. I looked at her in surprise. I had fantasized about her more than once but had never imagined she fantasized about me too. Hmm, that was very interesting. I looked at my sister in a new light.

“Ok, my pick,” she said a little angrily.