Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 10 by Zingiber Zingiber

Where do you begin?

Cheerleader ass first

Jennifer crawls up on the towel next to Chris. Now there are two pink bare butts on your bed in front of you, Jennifer's round and smooth, Chris's a little squarer with a little blond hair in the cleft, each with a sheen of slippery lube between the cheeks. You smile, stroking lube onto your cock, looking over your possibilities.

You put one hand on Chris's butt and one hand on Jennifer's and give each one a squeeze.

"You know what?" you say. "Ladies first." You slap Chris on the butt. "I'll nail you next."

You add more lube to your head and shaft and kneel behind Jennifer, working your cock between her pretty butt cheeks.

"God, what cute buns," you say. "Right about...there!" You press your tip to her back door.

"Go slow!" Jennifer says again.

"Don't worry. Okay, push out at me," you say. "I'll take it easy."

You've been up enough girl butt to think you're kinda good at it. You hold your stiffy on target, waiting for Jennifer to open. Jennifer pushes. There's a little hiss of wind and Jennifer's pink starburst opens for you. Her hot, snug hole swallows your cock head.

"Oh yeah," you growl.

You nod, adding to your personal count of asses tapped. Not every girl let you take them in bum and Jennifer isn't the only one picking up a notch tonight.

"Yeah, take him, Jennifer," Chris breathes. He's sitting up, watching as you slowly penetrate his girlfriend's ass.

You push forward, feeling her tight ring slide up your shaft. So hot inside.

"God, Jennifer, your ass is the best!" you say.

"Ooooh, slow!" Jennifer says. "You're bigger than Chris."

You take it easy, moving slow. Good manners mean you might be invited back. How could you turn down a sexy blonde cheerleader who's hot for you? She already wants you back in her pussy.

"So good," you sigh. You stop with your shaft about halfway in, and start up a rhythm of short, slow thrusts in Jennifer's ass.

"Ah, that's better," Jennifer says. "Yeah, slow. Like that." She sighs. "That's good. That's really good."

Jennifer quivers in front of you as you cup her buttocks and thrust gently.

"Oooh. Oh yeah, John, yeah," Jennifer says. "Feels so good."

You pick up your speed and depth just a little bit. Jennifer's ass is so hot and sweet on your cock, so soft inside, so tight at the ring.

Jennifer starts making little squeaks with your thrusts.

"Are you gonna come again, baby?" Chris asks. "Are you gonna come on his cock?"

"Ooh! Oh! Yeah baby lick me, get me off," Jennifer begs. She pushes up to raise her upper body so Chris can get under her. Jennifer's ears are flushed pink. Her blonde ponytail bounces as you move against each other.

Chris gets under Jennifer and puts his head between her legs. He reaches up with his tongue, sliding into her hairless folds and onto her clit. Chris's wild blond hair brushes against your legs as he eats his girlfriend out while you fuck her ass.

"Oh baby yes!" Jennifer says.

Jennifer's ass starts pulsing, squeezing down on your shaft as Chris licks her pussy. Her squeaks of pleasure get louder as you double team her most sensitive spots.

Chris sighs with pleasure as he licks away, feeling Jennifer tremble against him.

"Oh! Oh! Oh! Eee! Eek!" Jennifer says. She's lost her words, it's all moans, squeaks and squeals. She thrusts back against you, you have to be careful not to thrust back too deep.

Chris bends his neck up and sucks hard on Jennifer's clit.

Jennifer's head bucks up, and her butt presses back at you. "Eeeee......!" she squeals, screaming out another orgasm.

It feels so good, thrusting into Jennifer's hot ass as she comes on your cock. You promised Jennifer you'd fuck Chris while he nailed her ass, but you're not sure you can hold back.

What do you do?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)