Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 10 by analplay analplay

Back to her cunt or stick it up her ass?

There's nothing like a good butt-fuck

I’ve always wanted to fuck a girl up the ass. My wife would never let me do it to her. She insisted that it was dirty, and she was sure it would hurt. She wanted nothing to do with anything being stuck up her ass. But this girl- Jennifer- well, I didn’t know if she’d ever done it before, or if she enjoyed it or hated it- all I knew is that she couldn’t do anything to stop me. I was not going to miss a chance like this.

I stepped forward and, as she continued to finger her pussy, I spread her ass cheeks wider apart. I spit directly on her little brown puckered anus, and with a finger I worked the lubrication inside. I pumped my finger in and out of her asshole, enjoying the tightness and the heat. I stood up and placed the head of my cock right at the entrance to her backdoor. I pushed forward, and my cock pressed harder against her asshole. Pulling back on her hips, I pushed even harder, until, with a plop, my cock head broke past her sphincter and entered her bum. Looking up at Jennifer’s face, I could see a look of pain- her face was scrunched, her teeth were clenched. It was clear that she was not enjoying this, but she couldn’t do anything to stop it. Even as waves of pain rolled from her stretched out anus, she continued rubbing her tits and frigging her clit.

I pushed forward again. Inch by inch, my cock was pushed deeper into Jennifer’s rectum. Finally, after what seemed like hours, my balls came to rest on her pussy. The feeling of my cock, clamped tight in her hot ass, was like nothing I’d ever felt before. I started thrusting, ramming my cock deep inside her ass. Her body tensed up with the pain, and each time she tensed up, she squeezed down on my cock even harder.

Should I cum in her ass or her mouth?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)