Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 11 by analplay analplay

He wants to joint in, but on which end?

Popping Emily's Cherry

Billy’s cock stood attention, still glistening from Jessica’s aborted blowjob, as he looked from one end of the writhing pile of bodies to the other. He definitely needed to get a piece of Jessica, but there would be plenty of time for that. Right now, Emily’s pussy needed filling.

Billy climbed up on the bed and positioned himself behind Emily. His eyes met Jessica’s, and she slid her mouth down so it was only covering Emily’s clit, leaving her entrance free for Billy. Just for fun, Billy decided to start fucking Emily without controlling her mind. Let’s see what she how she reacts, Billy thought.

He slid forward, until he was straddling Jessica’s face. He aimed his cock at Emily’s cunt, which was hairless except for a small patch just above her slit. Into Jessica’s mind he pushed, “Reach up and spread Emily’s pussy lips for Billy.” Billy’s cock throbbed as he watched Emily’s lips unfold to reveal her sweet pink insides. He pushed his hips forward until his cock head came to rest at Emily’s opening.

The instant she felt Billy’s stiff cock press against her, Emily’s head bolted upright. She looked back over her shoulder, eyes wide and face dripping with Jessica’s pussy juice. “No! Please stop,” Emily screamed, “I’m still a virgin.”

Still a virgin, Billy thought, this is too good to be true! He slid forward a little more, his cock slipping into the warm entrance of Emily’s tunnel. “No- don’t!” Emily cried, as she started to get up, pulling her pussy off of Billy’s cock.

“Help Billy hold Emily down,” Billy pushed into Jessica’s mind. Immediately, she wrapped her arms and legs around her friend’s torso, locking Emily in place. Emily continued to struggle and cry, but she was unable to get away.

Billy placed his cock back at Emily’s pussy, and slowly slid inside. He pushed forward until he felt his cock butt up against some resistance. Emily felt it too, and she closed her tear soaked eyes and held her breath, bracing for the pain. Billy pulled back, and then forcefully thrust his hips forward. Emily let out a scream as she felt her cherry tear, Billy’s lance bursting through and continuing into her virginal sheath until his hips slapped against her ass.

Billy held still for a few moments, enjoying the feel of Emily’s clenching pussy, and allowing her time for the pain to subside. Then he pulled his cock back to her entrance. A small amount of Emily’s blood coated his shaft, confirming that he was the first man to have experienced what Emily had to offer.

Billy began thrusting in and out of Emily’s cunt, as Emily continued her sobbing. “Keep licking Jessica’s pussy,” he pushed to Emily, and she returned her face to the wet slit below her. Hungrily she devoured her friend’s muff, just occasionally letting a small sob escape her throat.

As Billy pounded Emily’s pussy, he felt a tickle on the underside of his cock. He looked down, and saw Jessica, tongue out, licking his cock each time he withdrew. She was doing this on her own, without his pushing! Billy pulled out of Emily and slipped his cock into Jessica’s mouth, sliding in until he reached the back of her throat. He thrust into her mouth a few times before returning to Emily. Jessica alternated her licking between the underside of Billy’s shaft and his scrotum. The sensation for Billy was exquisite, but he wanted more.

“Jessica, you will do the following,” Billy pushed. “As Billy slides his cock into Emily, you will lick along his cock to his balls. You will then suck each of his testicles into your mouth, bathing them in your saliva. Then you will continue your licking behind his balls, until you reach his asshole. The thought of tasting his asshole disgusts you, but excites you at the same time. You will lick around and inside his anus until he makes you stop.”

When Billy felt Jessica’s tongue press up against his asshole, he almost blew his load right then and there. Between his cock buried in Emily’s clenching, recently virgin pussy, and Jessica’s face in his ass, Billy was in sensory overload. Jessica’s tongue danced around the rim of his anus, sometimes lightly dipping inside, sometimes thrusting in as far as Jessica could reach.

Billy could feel himself getting close- he couldn’t hold back for much longer. He decided to have both girls join in his pleasure. “Emily, you will not be upset that Billy took your virginity. In fact, you will be aroused and honored. When he fucks you, you will fuck him back, and when he cums, you too will cum.

To Jessica, he pushed, “slide back under Billy’s cock, and open your mouth. With one hand, reach up and fondle his balls. When you taste Billy’s cum hit your tongue, you will burst with an orgasm.”

As Billy started thrusting again, Emily bucked her hips back against him, fucking herself on his cock hard and fast. When finally Billy felt the cum rise in his balls, he buried himself deep in Emily’s pussy and held still. His orgasm tore through his body, and as his first spurt coated Emily’s inner walls, she too was wracked by her own orgasm. Billy pulled put of her cunt and directed his next spurt into Jessica’s waiting mouth. Jessica began writhing underneath them, shuddering and trembling as her world exploded.

Billy continued ejaculating, coating both Emily’s pussy and Jessica’s face with his salty white semen. He collapsed onto Emily’s back, as all three lay there exhausted, trying to catch their breath. Billy’s flaccid cock lay against Emily’s swollen pussy, and from both dripped cum into Jessica’s open mouth below.

After a few minutes without moving, Billy felt Jessica’s lips wrap around the head of his cock. She began sucking his head and poking her tongue into his piss hole. She pulled his cock out of her mouth for a moment, telling Billy, “You’d better be able to get hard again, because you’re not leaving this room until you’ve fucked me!”

Can he do it? Does he fuck her pussy, or does he have anything else in mind?

More fun
Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)