Pit

She decides on the naive angel Pit. He should be easy to trick and his boyish features do make him quite cute. Samus heads down to the arena and finds him and approaches him from behind.

Samus "Pit, there you are."

Pit jumps a bit, not knowing she was behind him. When he turns around he's surprised at seeing her new latex outfit "Oh hey Samus. What's up?"

Samus "I was just wondering how you were doing, things are pretty different this time around. You having fun?"

Pit blushes and averts his gaze "Oh yeah this time it's pretty intense with those punishments. Bayonetta spanked me in front of the crowd."

Samus chuckles "I saw that one. I also saw the bulge in your pants it gave you. But I found something interesting looking over your previous matches. You never actually had sex yet, even when you won." Her gaze intensifies as her eyes start glowing pink "Tell me why." she tests her new power

Pit's face goes red at the question but his eyes go pink a second from the hypnosis. "No I haven't. This is all still pretty embarrassing to me and honestly I'm saving myself Palutena. I always wanted her to be my first."

Samus isn't surprised, he does always follow her like a puppy "But why wait? Pit you are holding yourself back too much. You need someone to guide you with how this world works. I'm going to set up a fight for us, if you win I'll do whatever you want me to. You're going to accept the challenge" She leans in and whispers the command in his ear while her hand traces a finger down his chest. She knows she doesn't have to tease him but she is enjoying watching him squirm.

Pit "Y-yes Samus. I'll gladly fight you." He agrees instantly. Samus smiles and goes to choose the battle settings.