One big surprise

Once your underwear is down and your cock is free you stand up a little straighter and try to control your nerves. Suddenly Nicole gasps, almost giving you a heart attack. "John, your dick!" She cries her eyes wide and her mouth agape. "W-what? What's wrong?!" You sputter out while hunching forward and trying to cover your member with both hands, suddenly concerned that your dick has some horrid deformation or growth that you've never noticed. "It's huge." She finishes in near disbelief. Still covering your groin you glance over at Nicole again, worried that maybe she's playing some sort of out of character prank, but the look on her face seems genuine. Looking from her to the rest of the room you suddenly realize that Nicoles exclamation has brought all eyes on you, or more specifically on your crotch.

Now that you have been abruptly made aware of your new audience you redouble your efforts to conceal your genitals but Sarah is not easily dissuaded. "Come on John, show us. A dares a dare." She says with a noticeable lilt of excitement to her voice. Glancing around you see Miranda, her eyes alight with curiosity as they stare at your crotch as if trying to burn a hole through your hands. Across the room Matt and Tom are both as naked as you but they seem to be all but forgotten. A quick peek at their dicks instills a sense of confidence in you that Nicole might have been telling the truth.

You close your eyes and take a deep breath before you take the plunge, dropping your hands away and allowing your hard cock to stand free. There's an immediate reaction, just like Nicoles gasp before but tripled in volume. Opening your eyes slightly you're greeted by the unexpectedly wonderful sight of three beautiful women marveling at your cock. There's a lengthy moment of silence as the three of them just stare, the mere sight of your cock having entranced them

Eventually it's Sarah who snaps out of it first, tearing her eyes off your dick to smile at you. "John, why didn't you tell me you were part horse?" She asks giddily. "We could have had so many private parties." As she says those last words she looks at you like a cat looks at a mouse and for a second you think she might pounce on you right then and there. Before she can Miranda interrupts with a question of her own. "John, if your dick looks like..." She trails off, licking her lips as she is seemingly unsure how to describe it. "Well, like that, why were you hiding it?"

You're not sure how to reply to that question, the answer that this was a surprise to you too feels ridiculous but it is the truth. You'd never gotten far enough with a girl that your dick was out and involved and compared to the porn you watched your dick seemed perfectly normal. It's only now, in light of the girls reactions, that you realize that maybe men paid to fuck women on film might have certain attributes that were above average compared to the standard male. However, you don't want to voice any of your naivete to Miranda, especially the fact that you're a virgin. Instead you think on your feet.

"I guess I was just being modest." You reply while trying to **** a smirk. All three girls laugh at your answer, maybe a little harder than the weak joke deserved. Notedly however there were two voices that were not involved in the hysterics. Matt and Tom. Glancing at them again you see them both glaring at you, their pants still down around their ankles. You can understand Toms frustration and in fact making that jerk angry is enough to put a smile on your face. Matts resentment however is much more disappointing. Obviously you understand how he feels now that you've monopolized the limelight but surely he must understand that dick size is hardly something you can control.

Speaking of dick size you can't resist another quick downwards peek, just for the sake of comparison. Matts dick looks about 6 inches long and fairly thin whereas Toms is maybe an inch longer and quite a bit thicker, but your ego swells as you realize how poorly Toms arrogant prick compares to your own. You have a good few inches on him in addition to some added girth. Even your balls appear bigger. It seems that Tom was all talk after all, not that you were ever worried he was anything else, of course.

"Can we get back to the fucking game please?" He shouts, clearly irritated by the lack of attention he was receiving. "Oh, alright." Sarah sighs, picking up the hat and handing it to you. "I think you should get the next pick John," she purrs, running a finger down your hand as you take the hat. "I hope you draw me, I'm looking forward to some fun." She adds with a not-so-subtle wink. As you sit back down again and everyone else returns to their positions you can't help but notice that Miranda is still staring at your crotch. She certainly seems to like what she sees.

Even Nicole, a girl who you've often thought of as a sister, can't seem to keep her eyes off your cock. When you catch her staring she blushes intensely and quickly averts her gaze but you can tell that she's still thinking about it. Thinking of you as a man for the first time instead of just as a friend.

All this new found attention feels...