Not even close

You don't hesitate at all, as your cock is already hard and set to go. You quickly get yourself into position, kneeling in between her legs. You grab onto your cock in order to line it up, and with one thrust, you slide right in. You feel the wet inviting warmth surround your member as you begin pumping it in and out. You focus on your rhythm, trying your best not to start off too fast, but it's a challenge to keep so much control. You look up at Olivia's face in hopes of seeing evidence of her enjoyment, but to your dismay she's not showing any clear reaction, she simply seems calm, or possibly worse, bored. As you continue swaying your hips, your hands begin to venture up towards her chest, you lightly caress the side of her breast while your other hand moves towards her nipple.

"Ah Ah!" Olivia says, quickly pushing your hand away. "You can only use your dick."

You pull your hands back as you look at the timer. A slight bit of panic begins to kick in as you notice how much time has passed.

"Not to worry you..." Olivia says, clearly noticing your concern. "But with the right toy, I could have cum twice by now."

Her teasing gets to you a bit, you're not sure what else to do but speed up your thrusts. The rhythm you had in your head vanishes as your controlled sways become wild jerks. The ticking of the timer becomes louder as you feel yourself building closer. Your slight panic turns into full panic as your mind attempts to think of anything to calm down your excitement, as you know you'll have no chance at winning if you cum now.

"At least one of us is close." Olivia says smugly, your face clearly giving it away

All you can think to do is go faster, fuck through your need to cum. You're body is practically flailing as you grab on to Olivia's hips simply to keep yourself from accidentally sliding out.

"DING!"

Your heart sinks as you hear the timer go off. It's clear by Olivia's face that you've lost. Your only consolation is that you can now cum. You give your hips another pump as your begin to arch your back, but to your dismay, Olivia quickly leaps back, pulling away from you completely.

"No!" You shout as you feel your opportunity to climax fade away.

"It wouldn't be very nice if you got to cum when I couldn't." She says with a smile. You breath in deep attempting to calm down from the disappointing excitement.

"Well, I made you cum earlier." You say attempting to at least get some points.

"You're right." Olivia says happily, maybe a little too happily. "And you did it with a toy."

You give up arguing as you realize you've only helped prove her point.

"But don't worry. Like I said, we'll still have plenty of fun." She says as she begins to stand up. "I'll even make sure you cum. We just have to use the right toy."